Home Page

Lieutenant Colonel
Alan George Stewart Smith, TD

Royal Engineers and Royal Signals

by
Lieutenant Colonel Edward De Santis

Ó
2018.  All Rights Reserved.

1.  INTRODUCTION  

            The principal references used in the preparation of this narrative were from a number of sources.  They include census records, official registries in the United Kingdom, medal rolls, army lists, the London Gazette and the officer’s service papers obtained from the Ministry of Defence.  All sources are contained in the REFERENCE section at the end of the narrative and are cited throughout in the ENDNOTES.  Where no source is cited for a specific entry, that information was found in the officer’s service papers.  These papers provided the majority of the details regarding his military service.  Every effort has been made to accurately portray the life and military service of Lieutenant Colonel Smith.    

2. 
EARLY LIFE AND FAMILY INFORMATION
 

The Grandparents of A.G.S. Stewart

            The 1871 Census of Scotland provides the following information regarding the grandparents and the father of Alan George Stewart Smith.  At the time the family was living at 30 West Maitland Street near the Haymarket in Edinburgh.  This is the first census in which Alan’s grandfather and father both appear. 

Census Place: St. Cuthbert’s Parish, Edinburgh, Midlothian

Name and Occupation

Relation

Marital Status

Age

Sex

Birthplace

 

Thomas Smith, Goldsmith

Head

Married

47

Male

Edinburgh, Scotland

Catherine E. Smith

Wife

Married

40

Female

England

Thomas B. Smith, Jeweler Shopman

Son

Single

18

Male

Edinburgh, Scotland

Stephen Smith (*)

Son

 

3

Male

Edinburgh, Scotland

Isabella Swanston, General Servant

Servant

Single

15

Female

Dundee, Forfarshire

The census form indicates that Thomas Smith employed 15 men and 5 boys in his jewelry business in 1871.

 (*) Stephen Smith would be the father of Alan George Stewart Smith.

 

Figure 1.  The Residence of the Thomas Smith Family at 30 West Maitland Street, Edinburgh as it Appears in 2018.
(Image courtesy of Google Earth)  

NOTE: 30 West Maitland is the building with the black door just to the right of the restaurant canopy.  Essentially it is the building in which the restaurant is located.  

            The 1881 Census of Scotland provides the following information regarding the grandparents and father of Alan George Stewart Smith.  At the time the family was living at 46 Queen Street in the New Town district of Edinburgh. 

Census Place: St. Andrew’s Parish, Edinburgh, Midlothian

Name and Occupation

Relation

Marital Status

Age

Sex

Birthplace

 

Thomas Smith, Goldsmith

Head

Married

57

Male

Edinburgh, Midlothian

Catherine E. Smith

Wife

Married

50

Female

England

Stephen Smith

Son

Single

13

Male

Edinburgh, Scotland

Jessie Greig, General Servant

Servant

Single

21

Female

Shetland Islands, Scotland

Figure 2.  The Residence of the Thomas Smith Family at 46 Queen Street, Edinburgh as it Appears in 2018.
(Image courtesy of Google Earth)

            Sometime between 1871 and 1881 Thomas Smith moved his family to 46 Queen Street in Edinburgh.  Isabella Swanston, the household servant in 1871 had moved on, presumably having been married.  She was replaced by 21-year old Jessie Greig.  Thomas Smith’s financial situation also seems to have improved somewhat as the house on Queen Street appears to be larger than the home on West Maitland Street.
           
The 1891 Census of Scotland provides the following information regarding the grandparents and father of Alan George Stewart Smith.  At the time the family was living at 18 Moray Place in Edinburgh.   

Census Place: St. Stephen’s Parish, Edinburgh, Midlothian

Name and Occupation

Relation

Marital Status

Age

Sex

Birthplace

 

Thomas Smith, Goldsmith

Head

Married

67

Male

Cramond, Edinburgh, Scotland

Catherine E. Smith

Wife

Married

60

Female

England

Stephen Smith, Hydraulic Machinery Maker and Leading Draughtsman

Son

Single

23

Male

Edinburgh, Scotland

Annie M. Robertson, General Servant (Domestic)

Servant

Single

19

Female

Liberton, Edinburgh

 

Figure 3.  The Residence of the Thomas Smith Family at 18 Moray Place, Edinburgh as it Appears in 2018.
(Image courtesy of Google Earth)

            Sometime between 1881 and 1891 Thomas Smith again moved his family, this time to 18 Moray Place on the west side of the New Town district near Comely Bank in Edinburgh.  The house on Moray Place was situated in a row of elegant town homes surrounding a central park.  Jessie Grieg, the household servant in 1881 also had moved on.  She was replaced by 19-year old Annie M. Robertson.  Thomas Smith’s financial situation seems to have improved even more in the preceding 10 years as the house on Moray Place appears to be yet again larger than the house Queen Street. 

            It appears that Thomas and Catharine Smith restricted their household staff to only one domestic servant, probably for economy reasons, and that each of the young women moved on during the 10-year periods probably to get married.  Figures 1, 2 and 3 also show Thomas Smith’s willingness to move to larger and slightly more elegant homes as his economic situation improved.  His son Stephen also began working sometime between 1881 and 1891 and probably was able to add to the overall family income. 

The Parents of A.G.S. Stewart

                Stephen Smith had received a Bachelor of Science Degree in Engineering from the University of Edinburgh in 1888.  This degree probably assisted him in obtaining a position as a hydraulic machinery maker.  In 1889 Stephen Smith was commissioned in the Royal Engineers (Volunteers).[1]  He later served as a Major and Honorary Lieutenant Colonel in the City of Edinburgh Royal Engineers (Territorial Force) and as a Commander Royal Engineers in the 39th Division during the Great War of 1914-1918.[2] 

            The City of Edinburgh (Fortress) Royal Engineers was a volunteer unit of the British Army under various titles from 1886. Its main role was defence of the Firth of Forth during the period in which Stephen Smith served in the unit.  Lieutenant-General Sir Andrew Clarke, Inspector-General of Fortifications from 1882 to 1886, did not have enough regular Royal Engineers (RE) to man the fixed mines being installed to defend British ports. He decided to utilize the Volunteer Engineers for this task, and after successful trials the system was rolled out to ports around the country. The Forth Division Submarine Miners was the fifth unit of Volunteer Submarine Miners, a new corps raised in 1886. The first officers’ commissions were issued on the 2nd of April 1887 and by the end of the century the unit was commanded by a major, with three companies. Initially, the headquarters was aboard the mine depot ship HMS Dido at Leith, the port of Edinburgh, but moved to Queen Street, Edinburgh, in 1905.[3]

            Alan George Stewart Smith was born on the 2nd of December 1895.  He first appears in the household of his father at No. 12 Murrayfield Avenue in the Murrayfield District of Edinburgh in the 1901 Census of Scotland as shown in the table below:

Census Place: St. George’s Parish, West Coates, Edinburgh, Midlothian

Name and Occupation

Relation

Marital Status

Age

Sex

Birthplace

 

Stephen Smith, Retail Jeweler (Goldsmith)

Head

Married

32

Male

Edinburgh, Midlothian

Margaret Smith

Wife

Married

36

Female

Edinburgh, Midlothian

Katherine S. Smith, Scholar

Daughter

 

8

Female

Edinburgh, Midlothian

Alan G. S. Smith

Son

 

5

Male

Edinburgh, Midlothian

Marjory L. Smith

Daughter

 

2

Female

Edinburgh, Midlothian

Catherine E. Smith

Mother

Widow

70

Female

England

Isabella M.A. Heggie,

Domestic Servant

Cook

Single

28

Female

Edinburgh, Midlothian

Marion Duncan, Domestic Servant

Nurse

Single

20

Female

Tranent, East Lothian

NOTES:

  1. Stephen Smith is noted have a Bachelor of Science Degree and was a Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh at this time.[4]
  2. Stephen appears to have inherited the Goldsmith business from his father Thomas Smith, who by 1901 was deceased.  His mother continued to live in Stephen’s household after the death of her husband.
  3. Stephen and Margaret Smith were noted in the census to be members of the Church of England.

            Stephen and Margaret Smith had two more children after the 1901 census was taken.  Stewart Alexander Stephen Smith was born on the 27 of October 1901 in Edinburgh[5] and a daughter, Marjory L. Smith with born in 1903.[6]

           

Figure 4.  The Residence of the Stephen Smith Family at 12 Murrayfield Avenue, Edinburgh as it Appears in 2018.
(Image courtesy of Google Earth)

Alan George Stewart Smith’s Early Years

            Alan entered Edinburgh Academy in January 1907, Classes 1a to 5a.[7]  He was a student of Science while at the academy and a cadet in the Officers Training Corps (Engineers).[8]  He did not participate in any sports, dramatics, musical events or other school activities,[9] apparently content to dedicate his efforts to his studies.  Unfortunately no photograph of him is available from the Edinburgh Academy as all the school’s group photographs do not show the names of the students in them.[10] 

            While Alan was studying at Edinburgh Academy his father was very active with his Volunteer military duties.  On the 31st of March 1908 Captain and Honorary Major Stephen Smith was granted the honorary rank of Lieutenant Colonel in the City of Edinburgh (Fortress) Royal Engineers[11] and on the following day he was promoted to the substantive rank of Major.  On the 17th of August 1908 Stephen Smith was awarded the Territorial Decoration (EVIIR).[12]  The September 1908 Army List shows Stephen Smith serving with the Forth Division (Electrical Engineers), Royal Engineers (Volunteers).[13]  

            On the 20th of February 1911, Stephen Smith was elected to the Royal Society of Edinburgh as an Ordinary Fellow.[14]  He was proposed for election by the following members in Billet 23/1, dated the 6th of February 1911:  William Falconer King,[15] James Currie,[16] James David MacDonald[17] and Sir Thomas Hudson Beare.[18] 

            Honorary Lieutenant Colonel Stephen Smith completed his period of active service in command of the City of Edinburgh (Fortress) Royal Engineers on the 20th of April 1912. On that date he resigned his commission and was granted to retain his rank and to wear the prescribed uniform of the Corps on appropriate occasions.[19]  He was 45 years old at the time and his total service was reckoned at 23 years.[20]  The London Gazette of the 16th of August 1912 showed that on the 21st of April “Major and Honorary Lieutenant Colonel Stephen Smith, Retired List, Territorial Force (late City of Edinburgh (Fortress) Engineers, Royal Engineers, to be Major, with the honorary rank of Lieutenant Colonel.”  Stephen Smith was not to be allowed to remain on the retired list for long, as the impending war in Europe would bring him back to active service in 1916.

            April of 1912 also was a significant year for Alan when he graduated from Edinburgh Academy and began to work as an Apprentice Engineer with Scott & Co., Greenock, Scotland.  Scott & Co. were shipbuilders.  Scotts Shipbuilding and Engineering Company Limited, often referred to simply as Scotts, was based on the River Clyde.  The company built over 1,250 ships during the period of its existence and went out of business in 1993.  

Figure 5.  An Advertisement for Scotts Shipbuilding & Engineering Co. Ltd., c. 1922.
(Image courtesy of Wikipedia)

            During the time that Alan worked for Scotts the company was gearing up for war production.  In 1914 Scotts was specializing in war and merchant shipbuilding and marine engineering of the largest types of vessels in addition to ship repairing. The company eventually grew to have about 5,000 employees during this period. 

            Scotts’ yard already had a long history of naval work which was longer than any other Clyde yard and had already made Dreadnought battleships before the outbreak of war. The company also had been experimenting with submarine designs and this held them in good stead with the Admiralty who ordered a number of different models during the war. The yard also made high speed light cruisers, torpedo boat destroyers, three sloops and a monitor.  Alan was already contributing to the war effort while working at Scotts.

            In October of 1914, two months after the beginning of the Great War of 1914-1918, Alan George Stewart Smith passed the entrance examinations for Edinburgh University in Higher English, Mathematics and Latin.  He left Scott & Co. and entered Edinburgh University as a student of Science, passing the 1st Year examination for a B.Sc. in Engineering.  He also was a cadet in the University’s Officer Training Corps (Engineers) as he had been when attending Edinburgh Academy. Meanwhile, his father rejoined the Colours as a Major in the Royal Engineers.  Although Stephen Smith was 47 years of age, his service was needed for the Great War, especially given his long years of experience in the Territorial Force.

3.  COMMISSIONING AND TRAINING  

            This section of the story of the life and military service of Alan George Stewart Smith actually will be a combined narrative of his service and that of his father.  Both served in the Great War; Alan until the end of the war and Stephen until the end of 1916.

            On the 4th of April 1915 Alan George Stewart Smith was commissioned a 2nd Lieutenant in the Royal Engineers Territorial Force.[21]  Following a short period of training,[22] made short by his participation in the Officer Training Corps (Engineers) at both the Edinburgh Academy and the University of Edinburgh, 2nd Lieutenant Smith was posted to the 2nd Line (Lowland) Divisional Signal Company, 65th Division, at Tillicoultry, Scotland.  Undoubtedly due to a need to have him receive Signals training, he was almost immediately posted to the Royal Engineers Signal Service Training Centre at Dunstable in Bedfordshire.

On the 5th of May 1915, after what must have been a short course at Dunstable, he was posted to the 1st Lowland Division Signal Company, Royal Engineers (52nd Division).[23]

            On the 1st of December 1915 Alan was appointed a Temporary Lieutenant in the Royal Engineers while his unit was at Bridge of Alan, Stirlingshire.[24]  During the early months of 1916 he continued his Signals training and other military training by participating in the following course of instruction:

·         Visual and Cable Signals Course at the Royal Engineers Signals Service Training Centre at Bigglewade in Bedfordshire.

·         The Irish Command Anti-Gas School Course in Dublin.

·         The Royal Engineers Officers Mounted Duties Course at Aldershot in Hampshire.

            On the 11th of March of 1916, while Alan was receiving this training, his father was appointed the Commander Royal Engineers (C.R.E.) of the 39th Division.  At that time the 39th Division was concentrated at Blaringhem, France, but Stephen Smith was in the U.K. at the time of his appointment.

4.  ASSIGNMENTS AND CAMPAIGN SERVICE

            By the 29th of March 1916 Lieutenant Smith was serving as the Second-in-Command of the 65th (Lowland) Divisional Signal Company at Chelmsford, Essex, the company to which he had originally been assigned right after he was commissioned.  However, he was not to remain with this unit for very long.  On the 29th of May 1916 he went to France to join the 35th Divisional Signal Company[25] and on the 1st of June he was promoted to the substantive rank of Lieutenant.[26]  On joining the company he probably was given command of a Section, a typical detachment of which is shown in Figure 5a.  The officer in the photograph is not Lieutenant Smith.

Figure 6.  An Officer, Non-Commissioned Officers and Other Ranks of an R.E. Signal Section in France during the Great War of 1914-1918.
(Photograph from a postcard in the author’s collection)

 The 35th Division on the Somme, 1916 

            The 35th Divisional Signal Company took part in the Battle of the Somme at Albert from the 1st to the 13th of July 1916.  The Battle of the Somme, also known as the Somme Offensive, was a battle on both sides of the upper reaches of the River Somme in France. The battle was intended to hasten a victory for the Allies and was the largest battle of the Great War on the Western Front. More than three million men fought in this battle and one million men were wounded or killed, making it one of the bloodiest battles in human history.  During this horrendous battle Lieutenant Smith and his company provided communications support to the 104th, 105th and 106th Infantry Brigades and to the division’s Royal Artillery units and Division Troops.  The company then took part in the Battle of Bazentin Ridge between the 14th and 17th of July 1916.  The British Fourth Army under General Henry Rawlinson) made a dawn attack on 14 July, against the German 2nd Army in the Braune Stellung from Delville Wood westwards to Bazentin le Petit Wood.

Figure 7.  Map of the Battle of the Somme, 1916.
(Map courtesy of Wikipedia)  

            During the entire war the 35th Divisional Signal Company lost a total of 13 men.  During the period that Lieutenant Smith was with the company they did not lose a single man.  See casualty details for this company in Appendix 1.

            Lieutenant Smith left France for home on 15th of August 1916.  No reason is given in his service papers for this move.  There is no indication that he had been wounded on the Somme, so perhaps his return to the U.K. was for a period of leave.  However, he was not to return to France until 1918 as he remained in England for the remainder of 1916 and all of 1917.  This long period in the U.K. was spent by him attending Signals training courses apparently in an effort to qualify him as an instructor.

            On the 9th of September 1916 Alan’s father, Lieutenant Colonel Stephen Smith, R.E. left England for France to assume his duties as the Commander Royal Engineers of the 39th Division.[27]  The engineer units under his command in the division consisted of the following companies:

 225th (Stockton on Tees) Field Company

227th (Stockton on Tees) Field Company

234th (Stockton on Tees) Field Company

39th Divisional Signals Company

Thiepval, Ancre Heights and Ancre, 1916[28]

            Lieutenant Colonel Smith arrived in the division just in time for the Battle of Thiepval, which took place between the 26th and 28th of September 1916.   The Battle of Thiepval Ridge was the first large offensive mounted by the Reserve Army under (Lieutenant General Hubert Gough), during the Battle of the Somme.  The attack was intended to benefit from the Fourth Army attack in the Battle of Morval, by starting 24 hours afterwards.  The battle was fought on a front from Courcelette in the east, near the Albert–Bapaume road to Thiepval and the Schwaben Redoubt in the west, which overlooked the German defences further north in the Ancre valley, the rising ground towards Beaumont-Hamel and Serre beyond. Thiepval Ridge was well fortified and the German defenders fought with great determination, while the British coordination of infantry and artillery declined after the first day, due to the confused nature of the fighting in the mazes of trenches, dugouts and shell-craters. The final British objectives were not reached until a reorganization of the Reserve Army and the Battle of the Ancre Heights.

            Lieutenant Colonel Smith also was present with the 39th Division during the Battle of Ancre Heights (1 October to 11 November 1916) and the Battle of Ancre (13 to 18 November 1916).  The Battle of the Ancre Heights is the name given to the continuation of British attacks after the Battle of Thiepval Ridge from the 26th to the 28th of September during the Battle of the Somme (See Figure 6 above). The battle also was conducted by the Reserve Army (renamed Fifth Army on the 29th of October) from Courcelette near the Albert–Bapaume road, west to Thiepval on Bazentin Ridge.  British possession of the heights would deprive the German 1st Army of observation towards Albert to the southwest and give the British observation north over the Ancre valley to the German positions around Beaumont Hamel, Serre and Beaucourt.  The Reserve Army conducted large attacks on the 1st, 8th, 21st and the 25th of October and from the 10th to the 11th of November.

            Many smaller attacks were made in the intervening periods, amid interruptions caused by frequent heavy rain, which turned the ground and roads into rivers of mud and grounded aircraft. The weather conditions put a great strain on the resources of the Royal Engineers field companies of the 39th Division and surely put a lot of pressure on Lieutenant Colonel Smith.  German forces in footholds on the ridge, at the east end of Staufen Riegel (Regina Trench) and in the remaining parts of Schwaben-Feste (Schwaben Redoubt) to the north and Stuff Redoubt (Staufen-Feste) northeast of Thiepval, fought a costly defensive battle with numerous counter-attacks and attacks, which delayed the British capture of the heights for more than a month.

            Stuff Redoubt fell on the 9th of October and the last German position in Schwaben Redoubt fell on the 14th of October, exposing the positions of the German 28th Reserve Division in the Ancre valley to British ground observation. A German retreat from the salient that had formed around St. Pierre Divion and Beaumont Hamel either side of the Ancre, was considered by Generalquartiermeister Erich Ludendorff and the new army group commander Field Marshal Rupprecht, Crown Prince of Bavaria and was rejected, due to the lack of better defensive positions further back, in favor of counter-attacks desired by General Fritz von Below the 1st Army commander. General Max von Gallwitz the 2nd Army commander, noted in early October that so many of his units had been moved to the 1st Army north of the Somme, that he had only one fresh regiment in reserve.

The 39th Division at Ancre Heights (1 October – 11 November 1916)[29]

            The 39th Division and the division engineers played a prominent part in the actions described above.  To be ready for the big attack intended for the 12th of October, Gough began to concentrate more troops in the area north of the Ancre.  The engineers certainly were required to prepare trenches for this troop concentration.  In early October the north bank of the River Ancre was held by the 39th Division under the control of V Corps up to the boundary with the Third Army at Hébuterne. On the 1st of October the 2nd Division was moved in on the left of the 39th Division to hold the ground from Redan Ridge to the army boundary. On the 4th of October the XIII Corps headquarters was brought out of reserve to control 1,500 yards of the front line up to the junction with the Third Army and the 2nd Division was relieved on the left by the 51st Division.  The 39th Division was transferred to the command of II Corps on the 2nd of October and then took over the area south of the Ancre on the 5th of October by extending its right boundary to relieve the 18th Division at Thiepval. By the 7th of October XIII Corps had the 51st and 19th Divisions in line and on the 8th of October V Corps relieved the 2nd Division with the 3rd and 63rd divisions. Gough issued instructions for the attack on the north bank from the 4th to the 12th of October and arranged for the 1st and 3rd Cavalry divisions to move close to the front line. The artillery of V Corps and XIII Corps steadily bombarded the German defences on the south bank where II Corps operations against Staufen Riegel (Regina Trench to the Canadians at the east end and Stuff Trench to the British at the western end, north of Thiepval) and conducted a simulated offensive with artillery bombardments, wire-cutting and smoke screens.

            The final objective (third line) of the British offensive was set at Beaucourt–the Puisieux road valley–second line. The British II Corps with the 4th Canadian, 18th, 19th and 39th Divisions was to advance from Stuff trench and Schwaben Redoubt to the Hansa line to force the Germans out of their defences, from Schwaben Redoubt–St Pierre Divion, as far back as Beaucourt, securing the road bridges by Beaucourt station and Beaucourt mill by 7:25 a.m. 

            The 39th Division attacked to the west of the 19th Division, with the 118th Brigade on its right flank. The brigade formed up on tapes laid without the German sentries noticing and one battalion advanced north about 1,100 yards to the Hansa line by 7:30 a.m., while three battalions attacked north-west to Mill Trench and then reached the station crossing and Beaucourt Mill by 10:00 a.m, the other two battalions got lost in the fog. At 6:15 a.m. the 117th Brigade attacked from Mill Road up the Ancre valley next to the river with one battalion and achieved surprise, despite a special barrage from twelve 18-pounders. The battalion cleared dugouts in the side of the river bank and along the top and then met some of the troops of 118th Brigade who were lost and joined with them to attack St Pierre Divion, which was captured around 7:40 a.m. Three tanks were to advance from Thiepval to assist but one was bogged on the drive to the village, the second broke down and the third reached the German front line at 7:00 a.m. then fell into a dug-out where it was attacked by the Germans. A messenger pigeon was sent by the tank crew for help but infantry arrived at 9:00 a.m. and the Germans withdrew.

            In II Corps, the 19th Division raided Stump Road and Lucky Way and began the relief of the 39th Division by extending its front to the Ancre, which was completed in the early hours of the 15th of November. In V Corps the 63rd Division continued an attack on Beaucourt Trench at 6:20 a.m. advancing from Station Road and losing direction in the mist. Some troops got to within 200 yards of Beaucourt Trench and waited for the attack due at 7:45 a.m. The 190th Brigade advanced on time, linked with the troops near the objective and entered Beaucourt, taking 500 prisoners and digging in around the eastern outskirts. Beaucourt Trench was captured on the left and troops began to bomb down it towards Leave Avenue but no troops of the 51st Division were found. Two tanks were sent forward to help mop up German troops holding out in the front line, one bogged but the other helped take The Strongpoint, where 400 Germans surrendered. Dugouts towards Station Road yielded another 200 prisoners. At 1:00 p.m. German troops were seen massing near Baillescourt Farm and dispersed by artillery; the captured ground was consolidated overnight.  On the 15th of November, the 39th Division completed the capture of Schwaben Redoubt.

            Lieutenant Colonel Stephen Smith was with the 39th Division through all of the actions described above and was invalided home in December of 1916.  He may have been wounded during the final phases of the Battle of Ancre, although this has not been verified.  He was 49 years old when he was sent home, so his release from duty with the 39th Division may well have been because of his age or from exhaustion resulting from participation in the battles in which the division had been almost constantly engaged between the 26th of September and the 18th of November 1916, all battles part of the follow-on operations of the Somme offensive.  On his return home, Stephen Smith was posted as the C.R.E. of the Merseyside Garrison, a position he held until May of 1919.  Lieutenant Colonel Stephen Smith retired from the Army in July of 1919.  He applied for his Great War medals on the 30th of April 1920 and he received the medals on the 19th of May 1920.

            His Medal Index Card shows that Lieutenant Colonel Smith was awarded the British War Medal and Victory Medal for his service and that he served in France, entering that theatre of war for the first time on the 9th of September 1916 as previously stated.  The reverse side of the card shows that the medals were sent to him at 31 Grange Loan in Edinburgh.  

Figure 8.  The Medal Index Card of Lieutenant Colonel Stephen Smith, R.E. (front).
(Image courtesy of Ancestry.com)

                        During the period that Lieutenant Colonel Smith served in the 39th Division in France (9 September - ? December 1916), the 39th Divisional engineers lost 6 Other Ranks.  No officers were lost by any of the companies during the entire war.  The following is the list of casualties suffered by the companies (by unit and in chronological order):

Regimental Number

Rank

Name

Cause of Death

Date

225th Field Company (1)

101179

Sapper

George Robert Crozier

Killed in action

15 October 1916

101184

Driver

George Frederick Hunter

Killed in action

19 October 1916

227th Field Company(2)

101316

Sapper

John Henry Loach

Died of wounds

27 October 1916

50782

Driver

James Tickle

Died

15 December 1916

234th Field Company(3)

131398

A/Corporal

Harry Kilvington

Died of wounds

11 October 1916

145557

Sapper

Ernest Cassey

Died(5)

16 December 1916

NOTES:

(1)   Total losses during the war: 36.

(2)   Total losses during the war: 31.

(3)   Total losses during the war: 36.

(4)   The 39th Divisional Signal Company lost 19 Other Ranks during the war but none during the period that Lieutenant Colonel Smith was C.R.E.

(5)   Where the cause of death is shown as “Died” the man was accidentally killed or he died of disease.

(6)   Most losses were suffered during the Battle of Ancre Heights.

(7)   Details of all the Royal Engineers casualties of the 39th Division may be found in Appendix 2.

            During 1917 Lieutenant Smith attended the Irish Command course of instruction for Signal Officers and Messing in Dublin.  On the 18th of May 1917 he was mentioned in the despatches of Sir Douglas Haig, dated the 9th of April 1917, and published in the London Gazette, Volume 30077, page 4878.  This Mention in Despatches will be discussed further in Section 7 of this narrative.

            Early in 1918 Lieutenant Smith returned to the Royal Engineers Signal Service Training Centre at Bedford to attend a refresher course.  On the 15th of March 1918 he was posted as a Signals instructor in “B” Depot at Bedford[30] where he remained for about a month and a half before returning to France on the 3rd of May 1918.  On the 9th of May he joined the 2nd Division, presumably the 2nd Divisional Signal Company.  He did not remain long with the 2nd Division, as he was posted to the VI Corps Signal School as an instructor on the 16th of June.  On the 29th of July he was posted back to the 2nd Division as the Officer Commanding the division’s signal school.

            On the 19th of August 1918 Lieutenant Smith was posted to XVII Corps Signal Section and on the 1st of November he joined the 2nd Brigade, Royal Field Artillery with the 6th Division as the brigade’s O.C. Signals.  He remained in this assignment until Armistice Day on the 11th of November.  He was again mentioned in despatches in the London Gazette, Volume 31080, page 15039.  More about this M.I.D. will be discussed in Section 7 below.

            Lieutenant Smith’s service papers indicate that he returned home on the 11th of November 1918.  However, the University of Edinburgh Roll of Honour indicates that he returned home in 1919.  It was unusual for any officer to return home precisely on Armistice Day; therefore, the entry in his service record is questionable.  One date is known for certain; he was demobilized on the 25th of January 1919.

Post Great War Service (1919-1925)

            Lieutenant Alan George Stewart Smith rejoined the Royal Engineers on the 11th of September 1919 at Bedford.  On the 6th of October 1919 he was posted to Dublin as the Officer Commanding Signals in the Dublin District.  On the 4th of June 1920 he was posted to Belfast as the Officer Commanding Signals in that district and on the 21st of October 1920 he was seconded to the 52nd Lowland Division Signals.

            With all of his time in the Army serving with the Royal Engineers Signal Service, it was to be expected that he would transfer to the Royal Corps of Signals when that corps was formed from the Royal Engineers.  This he did in Ireland on the 12th of January 1921.[31] 

            The Corps of Signals was formed on the 28th June 1920 when a Royal Warrant was signed by the Secretary of State for War, the Right Honourable Winston S Churchill, who gave the sovereign’s approval for the formation of a ‘Corps of Signals’. Six weeks later, on the 5th August 1920 His Majesty the King conferred the title ‘Royal Corps of Signals’.  During this period the Army surely was searching for well qualified officers to form this new corps.  Lieutenant Smith, with his war service and all the schooling and training that he had received, probably was a prime candidate to be recalled to the Colours to assist in forming this corps; hence, his rejoining in September of 1919 and his immediate posting as an O.C. of a Signals District in Ireland.

            In April of 1921 Lieutenant Smith was serving with the 52nd Lowland Division Signals with headquarters at 21 Jardine Street in Glasgow, Scotland (see Figure 7 below) while still on secondment from Belfast District where he was the Adjutant of the Signals detachment in that district.[32] 

Figure 9.  21 Jardine Street, Glasgow (still an Army Reserve Center).
(Image courtesy of Google Earth)

            On the 1st of March 1922 Smith was promoted to the rank of Captain (Provisional) while still serving with the 52nd Lowland Division.[33]  He now was listed officially as a member of the Territorial Army Reserve (T.A.R.).[34]  Soon after his promotion he was posted back to Northern Ireland where he joined the 2nd Dublin Signal Company.   During this time period Smith listed his residence as 31 Grange Loan, Edinburgh.  This was probably his father’s family address and one that Alan used as a permanent address.[35]

            On the 5th of August 1922 Alan Smith was appointed a Captain in the Territorial Army Reserve of Officers (T.A.R.O.).  His name appears in the London Gazette of the 4th of August 1922 on the T.A. Reserve Regimental List, Royal Signals, from the 52nd Division Signals.  The London Gazette of the 15th of September 1922 next shows him on the T.A. Regimental List, Class 1, 52nd (Lowland) Division Signals “To be Captain from the Active List (substitute for L.G. 4 August 1922) with seniority dated 1 June 1916.”  These multiple listings in the London Gazette and transfers from one category to another are enough to make one’s head spin.  This last entry is interesting because it provides him with a date of rank as a Captain of the 1st of June 1916; that is, backdating his promotion by some 6 years.  One wonders if he ever received any back pay.

            On the 4th of April 1923 Alan Smith was released from service with the Regular Army and was posted to the Reserve of Officers with the rank of Captain.  He was released from the Territorial Army Reserve of Officers during May of 1923[36] and began to work as the Assistant Manager of the Radio Communications Company in Glasgow.[37] 

Civilian Interlude (1925-1935)

            In 1925 Alan Smith left the Radio Communications Company and took a position as the Wireless Manager with the General Electric Company.  He left General Electric in 1927 and went to work for the British Broadcasting Company (BBC) in the company’s Operations Division.  During 1932 and 1933 he was residing with his wife, Mrs. Katharine M. Smith, at 64 Archerhill Road in Glasgow.[38]  From 1937 to 1940 he worked as the Senior Maintenance Engineer for BBC North Region.  

Figure 10.  The Smith Residence at 64 Archerhill Road in Glasgow, Scotland.
(64 Archerhill Road is the end unit on the left)
(Photograph courtesy of Google Earth)  

            In 1935 the Smiths were living as tenants at 15 Sydney Terrace in Edinburgh.[39]  

 Figure 11.  The Smith Residence at 15 Sydney Terrace in Edinburgh, Scotland.
(15 Sydney Terrace is the house on the left with the white door.
(Photograph courtesy of Google Earth)

Service in the Second World War (1935-1945)

            On the 2nd of December 1935 while working for the British Broadcasting Company, Alan Smith was transferred to the Class 2 Territorial Army Reserve.  This transfer did not in any way affect his civilian status.  The 1939 Army List shows him as a Captain in the Reserve of Officers, Royal Corps of Signals and his residence during that year was 4 Queens Road, Cheadle and Gatley, Cheshire.[40]  

            With war looming on the horizon, he was soon to be plucked from his civilian occupation and put back into uniform.  This occurred on the 28th of February 1940 when he was appointed from the Territorial Army Reserve of Officers and posted to the 2nd General Trades Battalion at the 2nd Signals Training Center at Prestatyn in Denbighshire, Wales.  He joined the unit on this same date.[41]  He was immediately granted Signal Pay at the highest rate under Article 385d of the Pay Warrant of 1940.  This is not surprising considering his Great War service, all the Signals training he had received while in the Army and the experience he had gained working for the BBC. 

            On the 18th of March 1940 Captain Smith embarked for the British Expeditionary Force in France.  His service papers indicate that he was performing draft conducting duties at this time.  The duty of a Draft Conducting Officer was to command groups of replacements heading to France to ensure that they got to where they were supposed to go.  This procedure appears to have been based on the idea (quaint to modern eyes) that a soldier or soldiers could not be trusted to get from point A to point B without being escorted by an officer.  Clearly, the Army believed this duty sufficiently necessary to tie up scarce resources such as reserve officers.  The question of campaign medal eligibility for Draft Conducting Officers is unclear, as it was difficult to determine for how long or how many times an officer had been in a war zone or in an area or at sea under hazardous conditions due to potential enemy action.  While it is not known how many times Captain Smith might have crossed over to France and then returned to England to conduct another group of soldiers, these duties certainly must have ended on or before the 26th of May 1940 when the evacuation of Dunkirk began.

            On the 11th of October 1941 Captain Smith was posted to the 2nd Holding Battalion at Rhos-on-Sea, Wales.  Once it was determined what his more permanent assignment would be, he was appointed Chief Instructor with the rank of Acting Major in the 2nd Signals Training Center at Prestatyn where he had been in early 1940.  He held this position until the 15th of June 1942 when he was again posted to the 2nd General Trades Training Battalion at Prestatyn followed almost a year later by assignment to the 2nd Army Detachment on the 17th of May 1943.  This detachment also was located at Prestatyn.

            On the 27th of July 1943 Acting Major Smith attended No. 36 Royal Signals Senior Officer Course at Catterick in North Yorkshire.  He successfully completed the course on the 18th of August 1943 and returned to Prestatyn, to the South Wales District Signals office.  He retained the rank of Temporary Major while in this assignment.  On the 25th of October 1943 he again was made Chief Instructor at the 2nd Signals Training Center.

            Major Smith moved to Abergavenny in Monmouthshire, Wales on the 1st of December 1943 where he was posted to “V” Headquarters Signals and on the 19th of December he assumed the position as Second-in-Command of this unit in London.  On the 17th of February 1944 this unit was redesignated 5 Headquarters Signals.  According to Lord and Watson (2003, p. 245) 5 Headquarters Signals formed part of CRS, SHAEF.  Listings of military abbreviations show CRS to mean Chief Review Services.  SHAEF, of course, means Supreme Headquarters Allied Expeditionary Force.  Precisely what kind of duties were being performed by Smith at this time is not known; however, it appears that in some way he was attached to General Eisenhower’s headquarters.  This became more apparent when on the 2nd of March 1944 his service papers indicated that he was serving as G.S.O.1 (Wireless) to the Supreme Commander at SHAEF and that he had been appointed an Acting Lieutenant Colonel.  Indeed, he had reached a rather lofty position in the command structure of the Allied forces.

            On the 2nd of June 1944, four days before D-Day, Alan Smith was appointed to the rank of Temporary Lieutenant Colonel.  It does not appear that he took part in the Normandy landings, as his records show that he flew to North West Europe on the 27th of September 1944.  He remained there until the 1st of July 1945 when he returned to England.  No explanation is provided in his service papers to indicate what he might have been doing in North West Europe during the 276 days that he was there.  The following is a short summary of the campaign in North West Europe that provides an overview of what was happening there during the period that Lieutenant Colonel Smith was there:-

            Following the Normandy Campaign, Field Marshal Montgomery's forces captured Antwerp (4 September 1944) and crossed the Albert Canal. The US First Army captured Namur and Aachen, while the US Third Army moved east and reached the Moselle. Montgomery's attempt to seize the lower Rhine by dropping the 1st Airborne Division at Arnhem ended in failure – “A Bridge Too Far.”  In November the Germans consolidated and in December they launched a counter-attack in the Ardennes known as the Battle of the Bulge. In January 1945 Montgomery's forces pushed forward to the Rhine. In March a massive bombardment at Wesel preceded a successful crossing of the lower Rhine by Montgomery's troops. The US Seventh Army pushed east towards Munich, French forces moved up the upper Rhine to Lake Constance, and the US Third Army advanced to Leipzig and across the Austrian border into Czechoslovakia. On the 11th of April Montgomery reached the River Elbe. Following the capture of Berlin by the Red Army and the suicide of Hitler (30 April 1945), Montgomery received the surrender of the German forces in northwest Europe on Lüneburg Heath on the 4th of May 1945.  Four days later (V-E Day), the war in Europe was declared at an end.[42]

            On the 21st of August 1945 Lieutenant Colonel Alan George Stewart Smith, Royal Corps of Signals was released from active service from the London District Reception Depot.  His service papers indicate that he was classified in Age and Service Group 1 and that his Military Dispersal Unit was No. 7 at Ashton-Under-Lyne.  Smith indicated that his permanent address was to be 6 Bancroft Avenue, Cheadle Hulme, Stockport, Cheshire.

Figure 12.  The Smith Residence at 6 Bancroft Avenue, Cheadle Hulme, Stockport, Cheshire.
 
(Photograph courtesy of Google Earth).

            Sections 1 through 4 of this work present the life and military service of Alan George Stewart Smith (and his father Stephen Smith) in a narrative form.  The remaining sections provide summaries of significant events in his life.

5.  PROMOTIONS, APPOINTMENTS AND ASSIGNMENTS

Promotions and Appointments:  Alan George Stewart Smith received the following promotions and appointments during his time in service:

Date of Promotion or Appointment

Rank or Position

4 April 1915

Commissioned 2nd Lieutenant in the Royal Engineers Territorial Force (T.F.)

1 December 1915

Appointed Temporary Lieutenant in the Royal Engineers (.T.F.)

1 June 1916

Promoted substantive Lieutenant.

1 March 1922

Promoted Captain (Provisional), Royal Corps of Signals, Territorial Army Reserve.

5 August 1922

Appointed Captain, Royal Signals, Territorial Reserve of Officers.

15 September 1922

Appointed Captain from Active List with date of rank of 1 June 1916.

25 October 1943

Appointed Temporary Major.

2 March 1944

Appointed Acting Lieutenant Colonel.

2 June 1944

Appointed Temporary Lieutenant Colonel.

24 April 1948

Granted the rank of Honorary Lieutenant Colonel.

 Assignments:   Alan George Stewart Smith received the following assignments during his time in service:  

Date of Assignment

Position

4 April 1915

Posted as a Company Officer, 2nd Line (Lowland) Signal Company, R.E.

5 May 1915

Posted as a Company Officer, 1st Lowland Division Signal Company, R.E.

29 March 1916

Posted as Second-in-Command, 65th (Lowland) Signal Company, R.E.

29 May 1916

Posted as a Company Officer, 35th Division Signal Company, R.E.

9 May 1918

Posted as a Company Officer, 2nd Division Signal Company, R.E.

16 June 1918

Posted as an Instructor, VI Corps Signal School.

29 July 1918

Posted as the Officer Commanding, 2nd Division Signal School.

19 August 1918

Posted as a Staff Officer, XVII Corps Signal Section.

1 November 1918

Posted as the Officer Commanding, 2nd Brigade Royal Field Artillery Signals Section.

6 October 1919

Officer Commanding, Signals Section, Dublin District.

4 June 1920

Officer Commanding, Signals Section, Belfast District.

21 October 1920

Posted to 52nd Lowland Division Signals, Glasgow.

1 March 1922

Posted to 2nd Dublin Signal Company.

28 February 1940

Posted to the 2nd General Trades Battalion, 2nd Signals Training Centre at Prestatyn, Wales.

18 March 1940

Posted as a Draft Conducting Officer with the British Expeditionary Force.

11 October 1941

Posted to the 2nd Holding Battalion at Rhos-on-Sea, Wales.

15 June 1942

Posted to the 2nd General Trades Battalion, Prestatyn, Wales.

17 May 1943

Posted to 2nd Army Signals, Prestatyn, Wales.

25 October 1943

Posted to South Wales District Signals, Prestatyn, Wales.

1 December 1943

Posted to “V” Headquarters Signals, Abergavenny, Wales and London.

2 March 1944

Posted as G.S.O.1, Supreme Headquarters Allied Expeditionary Force.

27 September 1944

Posted to duties in North West Europe.

 

  1. MILITARY TRAINING AND QUALIFICATIONS

Military Training:  Alan George Stewart Smith received the following military training during his time in service:

Dates

Course of Training

January – February 1916

Visual and Cable Course of Instruction, Royal Engineers Signal Service Training Centre, Biggleswade.

 

Irish Command Anti-Gas School Course of Instruction, Dublin, Ireland.

 

Royal Engineers Officers Mounted Duties Course of Instruction, Aldershot, Hampshire.

1917

Irish Command Course of Instruction for Signal Officers and Messing Officers, Dublin, Ireland.

1918

Signal Service Training Centre Refresher Course, Bedford, Bedfordshire.

27 July – 18 August 1943

Royal Signals Senior Officer Course at Catterick, North Yorkshire.

Qualifications:  Alan George Stewart Smith earned the following qualifications during his time in service.  

Date

Qualification

15 March 1918

Instructor, Royal Engineers Signal Service Center (“B” Depot), Bedford, Bedfordshire.

16 June 1918

Instructor, VI Corps Signal School, France.

11 October 1941

Instructor, 2nd Signals Training Centre, Prestatyn, Wales.

25 October 1943

Chief Instructor, 2nd Signals Training Centre, Prestatyn, Wales.

 7.  MEDALS, AWARDS AND DECORATIONS  

            Lieutenant Colonel Alan George Stewart Smith received the medals and citations shown in the table below during his time in service.  Although the British War Medal and the Victory Medal were the only two medals originally obtained by the author, Smith’s entitlements to the other medals listed are explained in detail below, based on information contained in his service papers.

Medal or Award

British War Medal, named to LIEUT. A.G.S. SMITH.(1)(2)

Victory Medal with Mention in Despatches oak leaf, named to LIEUT. A.G.S. SMITH.(1)(2)(3)

1939-1945 War Medal, unnamed as issued.(4)

France and Germany Star, unnamed as issued.(5)

Defence Medal, unnamed as issued.(6)

War Medal, unnamed as issued.(7)

Territorial Decoration (TD)(GVIR)(8)

NOTES:

 His Great War medals do not include the letters R.E. to indicate that he received them for service in the Royal Engineers.

Figure 13.  Medal Index Card of Lieutenant A.G.S. Smith (front).
(Image courtesy of Ancestry.com)  

            His Medal Index Card shows him as a Lieutenant in the Royal Corps of Signals with war service denoted by the X with 4 dots, shown to the right of the abbreviation Lieut.  However, the entries authorizing the two medals indicate that he was serving in the Royal Engineers (R.E.) when he earned the medals and that the authorization for their award is contained in a Royal Engineers medal Roll.  The card also indicates that the theatre of war in which he first served was France (which is correct) and that he went to France on 12-5-18 (which is incorrect).  His service papers show that he first went to France on 29-5-1916 and after quite some time in the U.K. he returned to France on 3-5-1918.  None of these dates coincide.

            The card also indicates that he received his medals on the 27th of March 1922 (See 27 3/22 in the lower left-hand corner of the card).  The back side of the card contains a note indicating that the Officer Commanding 2 Dublin Signal Company had sent a request for the issue of the medals on the 16th of February 1922.  Smith’s address also is shown on the back of the card as 31 Grange Loan, Edinburgh, the address thought to be that of his father.

(2)   The Royal Engineers Medal Roll for these two medals was published on the 26th of April 1922 also verifying their award to Smith while he was serving in the Royal Engineers.  Four other officers’ names appear on the same page with that of Smith and they are:

Lieutenant A.C. Richardson

Lieutenant D.K. Shepherd

Lieutenant H.E. Storey

Lieutenant E.H.J. Hanmer

            Oddly, no Medal Index Cards can be found for any of these officers for service during the Great War, and Smith’s card appears to have been produced after the war showing him serving in the Royal Corps of Signals.

(3)   Mention in Despatches (MID).  Smith’s Victory medal was purchased by the author with a mention in Despatches oak leaf attached to the medal ribbon.  Numerous searches in the London Gazette did not uncover any MIDs for an officer named Alan George Stewart Smith or A.G.S. Smith.  However, MID index cards and London Gazette entries were found for a Lieutenant A.G. Smith, Royal Engineers.  The first London Gazette entry was dated the 18th of May 1917, Volume 30077, page 4878 indicating that Lieutenant A.G. Smith had been mentioned in the despatches of Sir Douglas Haig dated the 9th of April 1917.  Two MID index cards were found for this entry both showing the officers to be in the Royal Engineers.

Figure 14.  Mention in Despatches Index Cards for Temporary Lieutenant A.G. Smith, dated 18-5-17, London Gazette Volume 30077, page 4878.
(Images courtesy of Ancestry.com)  

            While this Mention in Despatches may be for Temporary Lieutenant Alan George Stewart Smith, one would have to assume that his middle initial “S” was erroneously omitted from both the cards and the London Gazette entry.  This assumption may be valid when one considers that the “S” for Stewart might have been thought to be extraneous since it appears just before the “S” in Smith, or as sometimes the case, including all of an individual’s middle initials was considered to be unnecessary by clerical personnel making the entries on the documents.  However, the date of Haig’s MID may rule out the validity of this assumption.  Haig’s despatch was written on the 9th of April 1917.  A.G.S. Smith had been involved in operations during the Battle of the Somme, but he had left France in August of 1916 and had been at home for about 8 months before Haig wrote the despatch.  Based on the date of the despatch it seems unlikely that the A.G. Smith in the despatch could be A.G.S. Smith, however, the fact that both served in the Royal Engineer also makes coincidence unlikely.  Furthermore, Army Lists for the period do not show a Lieutenant A.G. Smith serving in the Royal Engineers during this period.

            The next London Gazette entry of interest is Volume 31080, page 15039 dated the 23rd of December 1918.  Lieutenant A.G.S. Smith had been in France since the 3rd of May 1918, so the timing of this entry could relate to his service.  An MID index card also was found for this entry.

Figure 15.  Mention in Despatches Index Cards for Temporary Lieutenant A.G. Smith, R.E. dated 23-12-18, London Gazette page 15039 (no Volume given).
(Image courtesy of Ancestry.com)  

            Again the same reasoning detailed above may apply to this MID; that is, the erroneous “S” and the fact that no other man by the name of A.G. Smith was serving in the Royal Engineers at the time.  Additionally, the timing of this MID and Smith’s service in France in 1918 makes it more plausible.  It is the author’s opinion that Temporary Lieutenant Alan George Smith, R.E. is the same Temporary Lieutenant A.G. Smith, R.E. and that he actually received two mentions in despatches for his service during the Great War of 1914-1918.

World War 2 Medals

            Since the World War 2 medals were issued unnamed, apparently they became separated from his Great War medals, perhaps sometime after his death.  Smith’s service papers do not show any of his entitlements to medals for World War 2, however, based on his service during the war he is entitled to the four medals listed in the table above.  The following information is presented in order to validate the addition of the four WW2 medals to his medal group. 

(4)   The 1939–1945 Star was awarded for specified periods of operational service overseas between 3 September 1939 and either 8 May 1945 in Europe or 2 September 1945 in the Far East theatre. The broad criteria were 180 days of service between these dates, with more specific criteria depending on service arm.   Army personnel had to complete 180 days of service in an operational command.  Smith served for 277 days in an operational command in North West Europe from the 27th of September 1944 to the 30th of June 1945, of which 241 days were served prior to the end of the war, thereby making him eligible to receive this medal.

(5)     The France and Germany Star was awarded for entry into operational service in France, Belgium, Luxembourg, Holland and Germany between 6 June 1944 and 8 May 1945 inclusive.  Again, Smith went to North West Europe on the 27th of September 1944 and remained there until the 30th of June 1945, thereby making him eligible for this medal.

(6)   The Defence Medal was awarded for non-operational service in the Armed Forces  during the period from 3 September 1939 to 8 May 1945.   In the United Kingdom, those eligible included military personnel working in headquarters, on training bases and airfields for the duration of the War in Europe from 3 September 1939 to 8 May 1945.  Those who qualified for one or more campaign stars could also be awarded the Defence Medal.  Smith served for 4 years and 131 days in non-operational areas during the war, thereby qualifying him for this medal.

(7)    The qualification requirement for the award of the War Medal 1939–1945 to full-time military personnel was 28 days of service during the war, wherever the service was rendered.  Smith’s service during the war of 5 years and 122 days obviously makes him eligible for this medal.

(8)   The Territorial Decoration (TD) was a military medal of the United Kingdom awarded for long service in the Territorial Force and its successor, the Territorial Army.  A recipient of this award is entitled to the letters "TD" after their name (post-nominal).  The criterion was for a minimum of 20 years service in the Territorial Force and Territorial Army, with war service counting double and service in the ranks counting half.   In 1930 the new Efficiency Decoration was introduced to be awarded to all three services, but when the ED was awarded to a Territorial Army officer it continued to be known as the Territorial Decoration and the recipients still used the letters TD after their name.  By the 27th of February 1940 Smith had served a total of 20 years and 137 days in the Territorial Force and Territorial Army, thereby making him eligible for this medal.  The medal that he received would have been the Efficiency Medal (King George VI).  The reverse of Smith’s medal probably would have been engraved with the date 1940.  This medal also had been separated from Smith’s Great War pair before the pair was purchased by the author.

Figure 16.  The Medals of Lieutenant Colonel A.G.S. Smith, Royal Corps of Signals.[43]
(Photograph from the author's collection)

The medals shown above are from left to right: British War Medal, Victory Medal with Mention in Despatches oak leaf, 1939-45 Star, France and Germany Star, Defence Medal, War Medal and George VI Territorial Decoration.

NOTE:  The King George VI Territorial Decoration marked “SPECIMEN” at the right of the group is a replica medal (that is, not authentic).[44]  

8.  MARRIAGE AND PERSONAL INFORMATION  

            Alan George Stewart Smith married and had at least one child, a son named Stephen James Stewart Smith.  His wife’s name was Catherine M. Smith (maiden name unknown).  Catherine was born on the 15th of May 1902.            [45]  Since Smith is such a common name, and with only her given name and middle initial, it was virtually impossible to obtain reliable additional information about her.  The date of their marriage could not be definitively pinned down through available research sources, nor could her date of death be determined.

            While the Smith’s son had three given names, no definitive information could be found regarding his date of birth or any other personal information.  His full name is only known because it appears on his father’s death certificate.   

9.  RELEASE FROM SERVICE  

            Lieutenant Colonel Alan George Stewart Smith was released from service after the Second World War on the 24th of April 1948.  His total service was reckoned as shown in the tables below:

Location

DATES OF SERVICE

PERIOD OF SERVICE

Great War Service

Home

4 April 1915 – 28 May 1916

1 year and 65 days

France and Flanders

29 May 1916 – 15 August 1916

78 days

Home

16 August 1916 – 2 May 1918

1 year and 259 days

France and Flanders

3 May 1918 – 11 November 1918

192 days

Home (demobilized)

12 November 1918 – 25 January 1919

74 days

Home Service During the Great War:

3 years and 33 days

Active Service During the Great War:

270 days

Total Service During the Great War:

3 years and 303 days

 

Inter-War Service (Territorial Force and Territorial Army) – Home Service

Royal Engineers (T.F.)

11 September 1919 – 11 January 1921

1 year and 124 days

Royal Signals (T.F.)

12 January 1921 – 30 April 1922

1 year and 109 days

Royal Signals (T.A.R.)

1 May 1922 – 1 August 1922

93 days

Royal Signals (T.A.R.O.)

2 August 1922 – 27 February 1940

17 years and 206 days

Total Service in the T.F., T.A. Reserve and Territorial Reserve of Officers:

20 years and 167 days

World War 2 Service

Home

28 February 1940 – 17 March 1940

19 days

B.E.F., France

18 March 1940 – 4 June 1940 (*)

79 days

Home

5 June 1940 – 26 September 1944

4 years and 112 days

North West Europe

27 September 1944 – 30 June 1945

277 days

Home Service During World War 2:

4 years and 131 days

Active Service During World War 2:

356 days

Total Service During World War 2:

5 years and 122 days

(*) Draft Conducting Duties.  End date may not be accurate.

Post World War 2 Service

Home

1 July 1945 – 20 August 1945

51 days

Royal Signals (T.A.R.O.)

21 August 1945 – 24 April 1948

2 years and 244 days

Total Post World War 2 Service:

2 years and 295 days

 

 

Location

Period of Service

 

Home Service

7 years and 164 days

 

Service Abroad

1 year and 261 days

 

T.F. and T.A. Service

23 years and 56 days

 

Total Service

32 years and 116 days

 

       

 10.  POST SERVICE LIFE  

            After leaving the Army in August of 1945, Alan Smith rejoined the British Broadcasting Company.  He was still a member of the Territorial Army Reserve of Officers at this time, but having exceeded the age limit for continued service he relinquished his commission on the 24th of April 1948 and was granted the Honorary Rank of Lieutenant Colonel.  His service papers show that his Personal Number was 2342 and his Serial Number was 593071.[46]

            Alan’s father, Lieutenant Colonel Stephen Smith, R.E. died on the 15th of February 1950 at the age of 83.  No additional information could be found regarding Alan’s two sisters, Katherine S. (1893 - ?) or Marjory L. (1903 - ?).  Other than his attendance at Edinburgh Academy, no additional information could be found on his brother, Stewart Alexander Stephen Smith (1901 - ?).

            In 1952 Alan retired from the BBC as the Head of Administration, North Region.  The first BBC North Region operation was a large region, based in Manchester and covering the areas now served by BBC North West, BBC North East and Cumbria, BBC Yorkshire and BBC Yorkshire and Lincolnshire. Regional radio broadcasting was largely based at a leased studio complex above a bank known as 'Old Broadcasting House' at Piccadilly Gardens in Manchester city centre. These studios became the base for radio output from the region in 1929.  Given the size of BBC North Region when Alan Smith worked there, his responsibilities covered a very large geographical area.

            Alan George Stewart Smith died on the 11th of December 1978 at 8 Beauvale, Newthorpe, Nottinghamshire.  His death was caused by a hemorrhage from a ruptured aortic aneurysm.  His son, Stephen James Stewart Smith, was the informant of his death.  His death certificate showed his occupation as a “Broadcasting Executive (Retired).”  Smith’s death was certified by C.A. Mack, the Coroner for Nottingham District, County of Nottinghamshire after a post mortem without inquest.[47]  

            Alan Smith’s will was probated in Nottingham on the 23rd of February 1979 with his effects amounting to £17,531 ($116,293.53 in 2018 US dollars).  The probate register gives no indication of the distribution of his effects.


APPENDIX 1.
35th Division Signal Company Casualties

APPENDIX 2.
39th Division Signal Company Casualties

APPENDIX 2.
225th Field Company Casualties

APPENDIX 2.
227th Field Company Casualties

APPENDIX 2.
234th Field Company Casualties

EFERENCES

 Army Lists

1.      Army List, November 1917.

2.    2. Army List, November 1918.

3.      3. Army List, January 1921.

4.      4. Army List, April 1921.

5.  
Army List, July 1922.

6.      6. Army List, 1939.  

Books  

1.      1. LORD, C. and WATSON, G.  The Royal Corps of Signals: Unit Histories of the Corps (1920-2001) and Its Antecedents.  Helion and Company, Solihul, West Midlands, 2003, p. 245.

2.     2. Edinburgh Academy Register, 1824-1914.  Edinburgh Academical Club, Edinburgh, 1914.

3.      3. War Supplement to the Edinburgh Academy Register, 1824-1914, Edinburgh Academical Club, 1921.

4.      4. University of Edinburgh Roll of Honour, 1914-1919.  Oliver and Boyd, London, 1921.  

Census Data  

1.      1. 1871 Census of Scotland.

2.      2. 1881 Census of Scotland.

3.      3. 1891 Census of Scotland.

4.      4. 1901 Census of Scotland.

5.      5. 1939 England and Wales Register.

Correspondence  

Email dated 7 February 2018 from the Archivist, The Edinburgh Academy.  Details from a letter sent to the Academy by Smith in 1973.

 

Documents  

Certified Copy of an Entry of Death, General Register Office, QBDAA 839022, dated the 15th of February 2018.

Internet Web Sites

 

  1. Royal Society of Edinburgh

https://www.rse.org.uk/fellows/past-fellows/  

  1. City of Edinburgh (Fortress), Royal Engineers

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_Edinburgh_(Fortress)_Royal_Engineers  

3.      The Royal Society of Edinburgh, Past Fellows

https://www.rse.org.uk/fellows/past-fellows/  

4.      Scotts Shipbuilding and Engineering Company

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scotts_Shipbuilding_and_Engineering_Company

  1. Battle of Thiepval Ridge

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Thiepval_Ridge  

  1. Battle of Ancre Heights

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Ancre_Heights  

7.      Oxford Reference.  North-West Europe campaign

http://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803100239604  

  1. British Army World War 1 Medals Rolls Index Cards, 1914-1920

https://search.ancestry.com/search/db.aspx?dbid=1262&enc=1  

Edinburgh and London Gazettes  

1.      1. Edinburgh Gazette, May 18, 1909, p. 537.

2.     
London Gazette, September 8, 1908, p. 6530.

3.      3. London Gazette, May 4, 1909.

4.     4. London Gazette, 19 April 1912, p. 2793.

5.     5. London Gazette, 16 August 1912.

6.      6. London Gazette, 4 May 1915.

7.     7. London Gazette, 16 May 1922.

8.      8. London Gazette, 4 August 1922.

9.     9. London Gazette, 15 September 1922.

10. 
Army List, April 1923.

 

Medal Index Cards (See Internet Web Sites)  

1.      Medal Index Card of Stephen Smith.

2.      Medal Index Card of Alan George Stewart Smith.

Medal Rolls

 

The National Archives of the UK; Kew, Surrey, England; WWI Service Medal and Award Rolls; Class: WO 329; Piece Number: 2174.  

Periodicals  

INSTITUTION OF ROYAL ENGINEERS.  Battle Honours of the Royal Engineers.  The Royal Engineers Journal, Institution of Royal Engineers, Chatham, Kent, 1925-1932.  

Registers  

  1. Electoral Rolls, Glasgow, 1932 and 1933.

2.      Valuation Roll, ScotlandsPeople.gov.uk

3.      Probate Register, 1979, p. 7648.  

Service Papers  

1.      1. Service Papers, Army Form B199A.

2.     2. Notification of Release, 21 August 1945.

3.      3. Notification of Officer “Casualty,” 30 March 1948.

ENDNOTES


[1] University of Edinburgh Roll of Honour, 1914-1919.

[2] In his civilian live Stephen Smith worked for Staff, Brown Bros. & Co. Rosebank Ironworks, Edinburgh and was at one time the Director of Housing, Manchester Corporation.  The Manchester Corporation refers to the City of Manchester government.  Smith would have served on the Manchester City Council in this capacity.

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_Edinburgh_(Fortress)_Royal_Engineers

[4] The Royal Society of Edinburgh, Past Fellows. https://www.rse.org.uk/fellows/past-fellows/

[5] Edinburgh Academy Register, p. 509.

[6] Ibid.

[7] Alan’s brother Stewart also entered Edinburgh Academy four years later.  He left the Academy in December of 1913.

[8] University of Edinburgh Roll of Honour, 1914-1919.

[9] Edinburgh Academy email of 7 February 2018.

[10] Ibid.

[11]London Gazette, May 4, 1909.

[12] Edinburgh Gazette, May 18, 1909, p. 537.

[13] In 1907 the War Office decided to hand all submarine mining duties over to Militia units and the Volunteer submarine miners were disbanded or converted to other roles. Several were converted into Electrical Engineers to make wider use of the coast defence searchlights that had been used to illuminate the minefields. Thus the Edinburgh-based unit became the Forth Division (Electrical Engineers) (Volunteers), but the Haldane Reforms came into effect the following year, under which all the Volunteers were subsumed into the Territorial Force (TF). The Forth Division was renamed the City of Edinburgh (Fortress) Royal Engineers.

[14] The Royal Society of Edinburgh, Past Fellows. https://www.rse.org.uk/fellows/past-fellows/

[15] William Falconer King FRSE FRMetS (17 April 1851 – 6 October 1929 in Hunter's Quay, Argyll) was a Scottish engineer. He was a pioneer in the laying of submarine telegraphy cables. A student at Glasgow University and then employee of Sir William Thomson, King was responsible for laying the first transatlantic telegraph cable to Brazil, while serving as chief engineer (1873–84) of the Western and Brazilian Telegraph Company. For his services in Brazil Emperor Dom Pedro II awarded him a Knight of the Order of the Rose.  He was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh in 1880. His proposers were William Thomson, Lord Kelvin, Peter Guthrie Tait, William Durham, and James Thomson Bottomley.  He returned to Scotland in 1884, living at Lonend on Russell Place in Trinity, Edinburgh. In Edinburgh he created the engineering firm of King, Brown & Co with Andrew Betts Brown based at the Rosebank Works in Leith and in 1894 King & Co, electrical engineers who built the Leith Electric Works at 1 Prince Regent Street and created the Leith Electricity Generating Station on Junction Place and installed one of Britain's first systems of electric street lights (1895) and Scotland's first electric tram system (also in Leith, 1910).  In the First World War his firm won the very lucrative contract from the Admiralty for the installation and repair of all electrical equipment in the Naval Dockyards at both Rosyth and Leith.  In later life he devoted much effort to the refinement of clocks and created a very fine chronometer which was installed in the Royal Observatory, Edinburgh on the Braid Hills.  He retired to Hunter's Quay in Argyleshire, where he had long kept a yacht and died there on 6 October 1929. Re: Wikipedia.

[16] James Currie FRSE MA LLD JP (1863-1930) was owner and senior partner of the international shipping company, the Currie Line plus a keen amateur botanist, mineralogist and archaeologist, making sufficient impact on the Scottish world of science as to rise to be President of the Royal Society of Edinburgh.  Re: Wikipedia.

[17] James David Macdonald FRSE FLS FZS FIB (3 October 1908 – 17 September 2002) was a Scottish-Australian ornithologist and ornithological writer. A traditional museum ornithologist, he did much to build up the collections of African and Australian birds held by the British Museum, as well as popularizing ornithology through his writings.  Re: Wikipedia.

[18] Sir Thomas Hudson Beare FRSE RSSA (30 June 1859 – 10 June 1940) was an eminent British engineer. He was successively Professor of Engineering at Heriot-Watt University, Edinburgh, at University College, London (where he was a colleague of Karl Pearson), and finally Regius Professor of Engineering in Edinburgh University.  Re: Wikipedia.

[19] London Gazette, 19 April 1912, p. 2793.

[20] University of Edinburgh Roll of Honour, 1914-1919.

[21] Army List, November 1917.

[22] Probably at the School of Military Engineering at Chatham, Kent.

[23] London Gazette, 4 May 1915.

[24] Bridge of Alan is a town in the Stirling council area in Scotland, just north of the city of Stirling. It lies on the Allan Water, a northern tributary of the River Forth.  Re; Wikipedia.

[25] The 35th Division was largely comprised of locally raised units known as “Bantams”, manned by troops who were under the normal regulation minimum height of 5 feet 3 inches.  The men of the Royal Engineers units did not necessarily fall into this category.

[26] Army List, November 1918.

[27] Medal Index Card of Stephen Smith.

[28] Wikipedia: Battle of Thiepval.

[29] Wikipedia: Battle of Ancre Heights.

[30] “B” Depot is where Signalmen and Linesmen were trained.

[31] Army List, January 1921.

[32] Army List, April 1921.

[33] London Gazette, 16 May 1922.

[34] Army List, July 1922.

[35] Medal Index Cards of A.G.S. Smith and S. Smith.

[36] Army List, April 1923.

[37] Edinburgh Academy email of 7 February 2018.

[38] Electoral Rolls, Glasgow, 1932 and 1933.

[39] Valuation Roll, ScotlandsPeople.gov.uk

[40] 1939 England and Wales Register.

[41] Other sources say he was called up for service on the 17th of March 1940.

[42] Oxford Reference.  North-West Europe campaign.

[43] These medals are in the author’s collection.

[44] The replica Territorial Decoration was provided by Peter Thompson of Poppy Medal Framing in the U.K..  It is hand-cast in lead from a mold made from an original medal and then aged to look like the real thing, although it is clearly advertised by Peter as a replica.  Peter’s web site may be found at www.poppymedalframing.co.uk

[45] 1939 England and Wales Register.

[46] His serial number being his Officer’s Army Number.

[47] Death Certificate.