Home Page

69348 Sapper
JOHN METHVEN
Royal Engineers  

and  

1867976 Lance Corporal
JOHN METHVEN
Royal Engineers  
(later Lieutenant, 7th Rajput Regiment)
NOTE: Please be sure to review ADDENDUM NO. 1 for this man to see additional information and corrections to the original narrative.

by

Lieutenant Colonel Edward De Santis, MSCE, P.E., MInstRE
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
(March 2022)  

INTRODUCTION  

            In 2007 the author purchased a medal group that consisted of the British War Medal and Victory Medal named to 69348 Sapper J. Methven, R.E. and the Haynes Medal from the School of Military Engineering named to 1867976 Sapper J. Methven, R.E. for being the Best Man in Field Works in 126 Party, in “A” Company, of the Royal Engineers Training Battalion.  The first two medals were issued to a Sapper Methven for his service in the Great War of 1914-1918, while the Haynes Medal was issued to a man who enlisted and was in recruit training after the Great War ended.  The dealer who sold these medals perhaps acquired them together from the Methven family as a “father and son” group or he may just have noticed the identical naming on the pair and the Haynes Medal that he had in his stock and assumed that there was a connection between the two men.  Just how the medals got together in one group is not known.  During the course of this research no familial connection was uncovered between the two men. 

            The life and military service of each man will be covered in separate sections of this narrative.  69348 John Methven’s story comes primarily from medal rolls and the chronology and war diary of the unit in which he served.  1867976 John Methven’s story was derived primarily from his Royal Engineers Tracer Cards.  

69348 Sapper John Methven, Royal Engineers

The 138th Army Troops Company

            Sapper Methven’s story starts with his military service records, as no information was uncovered regarding his family information or early life.  His regimental number, 69348, was the key to discovering the unit in which he served.  A study of casualties on the Commonwealth War Graves Commission web site found three men with regimental number in the 69XXX series who died while serving in the 138th Army Troops Company of the Royal Engineers.  Royal Engineers medal rolls listed 13 men with numbers in this series who received the 1914-15 Star, British War Medal and Victory Medal.  Finally, the war diary of the 138th Army Troops Company lists 21 men with numbers in this series. Of the 37 men encountered with the 69XXX regimental number, 19 (or 51%) were either senior or junior non-commissioned officers, indicating that they had probably been with the company since its formation.  Based on this information the author concluded that the 69XXX series of regimental number was assigned to the 138th Army Troops Company upon its formation and that Sapper John Methven was a man with the original contingent of this company.

            As the Royal Engineers expanded for service in the Great War of 1914-1918, in addition to divisional field companies, each Corps was organized with two or more Army Troops (A.T.) companies.  The A.T. companies were first produced by converting the four regular fortress companies already in France – the 20th , 25th , 31st and 42nd, and the two Special Reserve siege companies of the Royal Anglesey and Royal Monmouthshire Engineers (which each formed two A.T. Companies), and ten Territorial fortress companies.  In the spring of 1915 eighteen new companies, numbered from 132 to 149, were raised and trained at Buxton in Derbyshire.  Initially they were called Fortress Companies, but in August of 1915 they were renamed Army Troops Companies.  The 138th Company was one of these new Fortress Company of the Territorial Force.[1]  

Service in France and Flanders

            On 8 August 1915 while at Buxton, the 138th (Fortress) Company was alerted for deployment to France and proceeded to Southampton, arriving there on 9 August.  The company sailed immediately and was at Le Havre on 10 August.  The company began the march inland, arriving at La Buissičre on 12 August and at Annequin in the Pas-de-Calais on the 13th where it came under the control of British I Corps.[2]  At the time of its arrival in France the 138th (Fortress) Company was under the command of Captain John Palgrave Heathcote Ouchterlony, R.E.[3]

Figure 1.  Major John Palgrave Heathcote Ouchterlony, DSO, R.E.
(Photograph courtesy of De Ruvigny's Roll of Honour, 1914-1919)

            On 17 August 1915 while the company was at Annequin, it was re-designated the 138th Army Troops Company.  Ten days later (27 August), while still under the control of British I Corps, the company moved to Mazingarbe.[4]  Sapper John Methven joined the company on 6 September 1915 at Mazingarbe.[5]

            The 138th Army Troops Company would remain in the Pas-de-Calais sector of France supporting various Corps in the rear area until the summer of 1917 when it moved into Belgium to take part in the Battle of Pilckem, near Ypres. 

Figure 2.  The Great War Medal Index Card of 69348 Sapper John Methven, R.E.
(Image courtesy of Ancestry.com)

The Work of the 138th Army Troops Company

            The 138th Company worked in Corps rear areas primarily on water supply, corps defence lines, observation posts for artillery, gun positions for heavy artillery, trench tramways, road-screening, corps engineer dumps and workshops and erection of hangars for the Royal Flying Corps.  Army Troops Companies were smaller than divisional field companies.  They were established with three officers and 139 other ranks, but they were provided with mechanical transport which was an advantage they had over the divisional companies.[6]

            Although the company worked primarily in the rear area, it was not immune from battle casualties as will be seen in the next section describing the chronology of the company.  In fact, the company suffered 14 Other Ranks casualties during the war, the details of which are included in Appendix No. 1.  This was a casualty rate of approximately 10 percent of its authorized strength.  No officer casualties were found during this research project except for Major Ouchterlony, who was killed in action while serving with another unit.

Chronology of Service of the 138th Army Troops Company[7]

            The following is a chronological outline of the service of the company in France and Flanders.  It includes the locations of the company headquarters on certain dates, the campaigns and battles in which it participated and the casualties it suffered during its time in the theater of war.  Sapper Methven’s presence in the battles listed can only be assumed.  There may have been times when he was not present in the unit, such as times when he was in hospital or granted leave.  It must be stated here that his name does not appear anywhere in the unit war diary.  Although the diary pages are difficult to read, a careful study of them by the author found no specific mention of Methven.

25 September – 5 October 1915:        The company was under British IV Corps control                                                                 during the Battle of Loos.

1 February 1916:                                 Company at Lozinghem.

13 March 1916:                                   Company at Gouy-Servins.  During this period the company war diary shows many admissions to hospital for various ailments.  During most of 1916 the company worked on rear area projects with                                                                     sections located at various locations throughout the Lozinghem area. 

10 January 1917:                                 The company war diary lists the first casualty of the war stating that 80865 Driver William Powell was “found dead.”  No explanation is given for his death.[8]

2 March 1917:                                     Company at Avesnes Les Bapaume.

3-17 May 1917:                                   The company took part in the Battle of Bullecourt with I ANZAC Corps.

June 1917:                                           The company suffered many casualties wounded in action, probably associated with the Bullecourt action.

15 July 1917:                                       69451 Corporal Charles John Jackson, killed in action. His death was not entered in the company war diary until 21 July.

31 July – 2 August 1917:                    The company was engaged in the Battle of Pilckem with British XIX Corps.

16-18 August 1917:                            The company took part in the Battle of Langemarck with British XIX Corps.

21 August 1917:                                 The death of 51500 Lance Corporal Thomas Percey Horton was recorded in the war diary, probably as a result of the action at Langemarck. Horton was killed in action.

6 September 1917:                              The death of 93055 Sapper Manus Devine was listed in the war diary as killed in action.[9]

20-25 September 1917:                       The company took part in the Battle of Menin Road with British V Corps.

26 September – 3 October 1917:        The company was engaged in the Battle of Polygon Wood with II ANZAC Corps.

4 October 1917:                                  The company took part in the Battle of Broodseinde with II ANZAC Corps.

6 October 1917:                                  Lance Corporal Ernest Goodhead, killed in action.[10]

7 October 1917:                                  The company was engaged in the Battle of Poelcappelle with II ANZAC Corps.

12 October 1917:                                The company took part in the First Battle of  Passchendaele with II ANZAC Corps.

26 October – 10 November 1917:      The company was involved in the Second Battle of Passchendaele with the Canadian Corps.  The company headquarters at this time was at Dixmude.  This battle cost the company many wounded in                                                            action along with the following fatalities:

                                                            143747 Sapper Edmund Spencer Smith, died of wounds, 28 October.[11]

                                                            69338 Sapper Hugh Whitehill, killed in action 28 October.

                                                            146575 Sapper Leonard Charles Russell, died of wounds, 28 October.

                                                             97373 Sapper Christopher George Baker, died of wounds, 30 October.[12]  

12 April 1918:                                     Company at Brandock.  

25-26 April 1918:                                Company took part in the Battle of Kemmel with British II Corps.  

29 April 1918:                                     Company took part in the Battle of Scherpenberg with British II Corps.

16 May 1918:                                      17726 Sapper Sydney Concentine Smith, killed in action.[13]          

                                                            41535 Lance Corporal Peter John Whittet, killed in action.[14]

24 August 1918:                                 86867 Driver William Chad, died.[15]  

26 September 1918:                            69341 Sergeant Jesse Colley, killed in action.[16]

28 September – 2 October 1918:        Company engaged in the Battle of Ypres with British II Corps.

14-19 October 1918:                           Company engaged in the Battle of Courtrai with British II Corps.

29 April 1919:                                     69348 Sapper John Methven was transferred to the Class”Z” Reserve in the U.K..[17]

            Following the Armistice on 11 November 1918 the 138th Army Troops Company suffered two additional fatalities.  On 19 July 1919 155075 Lance Corporal W. Brand died in France.  On 4 September 1919 606596 Pioneer W. McBride died.  He also died in France.  It appears that the 138th Army Troops Company was not immediately demobilized after the war.  Although Methven returned to the U.K. in the spring of 1919 for demobilization, a portion of the company remained in France.  Methven’s early demobilization was probably due to the fact that he was one of the original men in the company to go to France in April of 1915.

            On 8 January 1920 Methven was awarded the 1914-15 Star for his service in the Great War.  Shortly thereafter he received the British War Medal and Victory Medal.[18]  No additional information is know about John Methven after his release from the Army.

Service Medals

            As indicated above, 69348 Sapper John Methven received the 1914-15 Star for his service in France and Flanders with the 138th Army Troops Company.  Unfortunately this medal was not in the group of medals purchased by the author.  At some point the medal was separated from the British War Medal and Victory Medal, perhaps by a family member or perhaps by another collector.  Its present whereabouts is unknown.  The Methven medals in the author’s collection are shown in Figure 3 below.  Both medals are named to Methven on their rims in impressed upper case lettering as follows:

69348 SPR. J. METHVEN. R.E.

Figure 3.  The British War Medal and Victory Medal of Sapper John Methven, R.E.
(Photograph from the author’s collection)


APPENDIX NO. 1.
CASUALTIES OF THE 138TH ARMY TROOPS COMPANY

EDMUND SPENCER SMITH
Sapper
Service Number: 143747

 

138th Army Troops Coy
Royal Engineers

 

 

Died 28 October 1917
43 years old

 

NINE ELMS BRITISH CEMETERY
VII. E. 20.
Belgium

 

HUGH WHITEHILL
Sapper
Service Number: 69338

 

138th Army Troops Coy
Royal Engineers

 

 

Died 28 October 1917

 

YPRES RESERVOIR CEMETERY
I. I. 41.
Belgium

 

Charles John JACKSON
Corporal
Service Number: 69451

 

138th Army Troops Coy
Royal Engineers

 

 

Died 15 July 1917

 

NEW IRISH FARM CEMETERY
XXXIV. A. 10.
Belgium

 

THOMAS PERCY HORTON
Lance Corporal
Service Number: 51500

 

138th Army Troops Coy
Royal Engineers

 

 

Died 21 August 1917

 

BRANDHOEK NEW MILITARY CEMETERY NO.3
I. B. 11.
Belgium

 

LEONARD  CHARLES RUSSELL
Sapper
Service Number: 146575

 

138th Army Troops Coy
Royal Engineers

 

 

Died 28 October 1917

 

YPRES RESERVOIR CEMETERY
I. I. 40.
Belgium

 

MANUS DEVINE
Sapper
Service Number: 93055

 

138th Army Troops Coy.
Royal Engineers

 

 

Died 06 September 1917
24 years old

 

BRANDHOEK NEW MILITARY CEMETERY NO.3
I. E. 35.
Belgium

 

W. BRAND
Lance Corporal
Service Number: 155075

 

138th Army Troops Coy
Royal Engineers

 

 

Died 19 July 1919

 

TINCOURT NEW BRITISH CEMETERY
VII. D. 18.
France

 

CHRISTOPHER  GEORGE  BAKER
Sapper
Service Number: 97373

 

138th Army Troops Coy
Royal Engineers

 

 

Died 30 October 1917

 

OXFORD ROAD CEMETERY
I. I. 11.
Belgium

 

W. McBRIDE
Pioneer
Service Number: 606596

 

138th Army Troops Coy.
Royal Engineers

 

 

Died 04 September 1919

 

TINCOURT NEW BRITISH CEMETERY
VII. H. 12.
France

 

SYDNEY CONCENTINE SMITH
Sapper
Service Number: 17726

 

138th Army Troops Coy
Royal Engineers

 

Died 16 May 1918
30 years old

 

CANADA FARM CEMETERY
IV. A. 17.
Belgium

 

 

PETER JOHN WHITTET
Lance Corporal
Service Number: 41535

 

138th Army Troops Coy
Royal Engineers

 

Died 16 May 1918
26 years old

 

CANADA FARM CEMETERY
IV. A. 16.
Belgium

WILLIAM POWELL
Driver
Service Number: 80865

138th Army Troops Coy
Royal Engineers

Died 10 January 1917
37 years old

GORDON DUMP CEMETERY, OVILLERS-LA BOISSELLE
VI. D. 14.
France

 

WILLIAM CHAD
Driver
Service Number: 80867

138th Army Troop Coy
Royal Engineers

 

Died 24 August 1918
40 years old

DOZINGHEM MILITARY CEMETERY
XIV. G. 9.
Belgium

 

JESSE COLLEY
Serjeant
Service Number: 69341

 

138th Army Troop Coy.
Royal Engineers

 

Died 26 September 1918
38 years old

 

DOZINGHEM MILITARY CEMETERY
XIV. G. 11.
Belgium

NOTE:  The table above is from the Commonwealth War Graves Commission web site.  

Figure 4.  A group of Royal Engineers at work on a light railway line near Boesinghe, grouped around a flat truck, 31 July - 2 August, Battle of Pilckem Ridge.
(Photograph courtesy of Wikipedia)


1867976  LANCE CORPORAL John Methven, Royal Engineers  
(later Lieutenant, 7th Rajput Regiment)

  1. FAMILY INFORMATION

            John Methven was born in Edinburgh, Scotland on 19 April 1910.  He was the son of John Methven (1882-1965) and Janet Methven (1884-1940), née Sime.  John and Janet had married in Edinburgh on 29 June 1906 and had two children before the birth of their son John; William Sime Methven (1907-1909) and Margaret Scott Methven (1908-1967).  John and Janet Methven had two more children after the birth of young John.  They were James Boswell Sime Methven (1913-1992) and Oliver Methven (1920-1975).[19]  

2.  ENLISTMENT AND TRAINING  

Enlistment

            John Methven enlisted in the Royal Engineers on 1 May 1929 at the age of 19 for a period of 6 years with the Colours and 6 years in the Army Reserve.  Following the approval of his attestation he was assigned Army Number 1867976 and was posted to “A” Company of the Royal Engineers Training Battalion at Chatham, Kent.[20]                 

Training

            At the time that Methven was posted to the R.E. Training Battalion, the battalion commander was Lieutenant Colonel O.H.B. Trenchard, R.E. and the officer commanding “A” Company was Captain Kenneth Macaulay Papworth, MC, R.E.  Two other officers were serving in “A” Company at the time; Lieutenant W.J. Dynes, R.E.[21] and Lieutenant John Guise Cowley, R.E.[22] 

             Methven’s training began with the basics that were required for each man to learn to be a soldier.  This involved military customs, the wearing of his uniform and insignia, military discipline and the use, care and maintenance of his weapon, the short, magazine Lee-Enfield rifle (SMLE).  Following a period of basic training, Methven then received the training necessary to make him an engineer soldier.  This involved such field engineering subjects as tunnelling, trench-building, camouflaging techniques, barbed-wire entanglements, construction and clearing of obstacles, bridging, explosives and demolitions, surveying and other skills necessary to support the infantry and artillery in the field.  

            Methven excelled in field engineering and was and was awarded the Haynes Medal for being the best man in field works in his party (No. 126).  He also appears to have displayed a talent for surveying, as he left the School of Military Engineering with the Corps Trade of Surveyor (Ordnance), Class A III.[23] 

Figure 5. Sir John Guise Cowley as a Lieutenant General.
(Image courtesy of the National Portrait Gallery)

3.  POSTINGS, ASSIGNMENTS AND CAMPAIGN SERVICE

Royal Engineers Survey Battalion (10 June 1930 - 31 January 1941)

            Sapper Methven was posted to the Survey Battalion, R.E. on 10 June 1930 after completing his training at Chatham.  Presumably he was posted to Southampton where the headquarters of the battalion was located.  The commander of the Survey Battalion at that time was Colonel G.S.C. Cooke, DSO.  Other officers of the battalion at Southampton included the following:

·         Major Geoffrey Cheetam, DSO, MC, R.E. (Second in Command)[24]

·         Captain H.A. Bazley, R.E. (Adjutant)[25]

·         Captain T.E. Longfield, R.E.

·         Captain D.R. Martin, R.E.

·         Lieutenant R.H. Denniss, R.E.

·         Captain (Quartermaster) G.T. Northover, R.E.

            In July of 1934 Sapper Methven re-engaged to complete 21 years of service with the Colours and on 1 January 1938 he was appointed a Lance Corporal.  It appears that during this time and up until the early years of World War 2 he continued to be posted to survey duties.  His tracer card shows that as late as 2 September 1939 he was still serving in “Survey Units,” although the specific units were not specified.  Unfortunately his tracer cards do not show subsequent promotions above the rank of Lance Corporal, promotions that he certainly must have received.

No. 8 Commando (1 February 1941 – 31 August 1941)[26]

            On 1 February 1941 an interesting event occurred in Methven’s military career.  He was posted to No. 8 Commando.   The Commando was formed in June 1940 primarily from members of the Brigade of Guards. It was one of the units selected to be sent to the Middle East as part of Layforce.[27]

Figure 6.  Colonel Robert Edward Laycock.[28]
(Photograph courtesy of Wikipedia)

            On arrival in the Middle East No. 8 Commando became known as 'B' Battalion in an attempt at deception, not wanting the Axis forces to know there was a commando formation in the theatre of war. The commando participated in the Battle of Crete and in North Africa around Tobruk before being disbanded in late 1941. After this, many of its personnel went on to serve in other commando units formed in the area, including the Special Air Service.

            Raised in June 1940 No. 8 Commando was formed mainly from volunteers from London District, and included men from the Household Cavalry, Foot Guards, Somerset Light Infantry, Royal Engineers, Royal Artillery and the Royal Marines. In October 1940, as part of a reorganization of the Commando formations, the unit was amalgamated with No. 3 Commando into a single special service battalion known as the 4th Special Service Battalion. As a part of this organisation, the unit’s name was changed to 'B' Special Service Company.

            In January 1941 the special service battalion organisation was disbanded and the commando designation was readopted. As a result, No. 8 (Guards) Commando was split from No. 3 Commando and raised back up to battalion strength.  Methven appears to have joined the unit shortly after this.  He may have been chosen to join the Commando because of his expertise in field works (or maybe surveying).

            Initially, training was fairly rudimentary and consisted mainly of "forced marches and heavy pressure"; however, more training in operating with assault landing craft was undertaken later on and No. 8 Commando moved up to the small seaside town of Largs, on the coast in Ayrshire, Scotland where they were billeted by the townspeople and remained for about a month. The next move was to the town of Lamlash, on the island of Arran. Shortly after arriving there, the unit was disbanded and most of the men were "returned to unit" because their performance during training had not been up to standard.

            In February 1941, with an establishment of 38 officers and 502 other ranks, they embarked for the Middle East. Along with No. 7, No. 11 (Scottish), No. 50 and No. 52 Commandos they became part of Layforce and were redesignated 'B' Battalion.  Methven appears to have been with the unit at this time.  ‘B’ Battalion did not take part in the unsuccessful raid on Bardia, but on 27 May 1941, after a previously unsuccessful landing attempt two days earlier, a detachment landed on Crete with 'A' Battalion (No. 7 Commando) and 'D' Battalion (Nos. 50 and 52 Commandos) in an effort to stem the tide of the German attack on the island long enough for the garrison to be evacuated.

            Throughout a period of five days from 27 to 31 May No. 8 Commando fought a series of rearguard actions around Sphakia, before they too were evacuated. By that time, however, there were few vessels left and as a consequence many of the unit's men were left behind and subsequently captured. Of the 800 men from Layforce that were sent to Crete, only about 200 escaped.  Methven appears to have been one of the men who escaped as no record has been found of his being captured.

            Following the evacuation from Crete, a detachment from No. 8 (Guards) Commando consisting of five officers and 70 other ranks was sent to Tobruk, which was at the time was under siege. In June the Allies launched Operation Battleaxe, an attempt to relieve the garrison. Within this situation it was decided that the commandos in Tobruk could be used to carry out raids against the positions facing them. In the middle of the month the detachment from No. 8 (Guards) Commando began carrying out patrols in an effort to become familiar with the terrain and to practice moving at night. It was then decided that they would carry out a raid on an Italian position that was dominating the forward areas of the Indian 18th Cavalry. The position, which was known as the Twin Pimples, consisted of two small hills that sat close together and from where the Italians were able to observe the Allied lines.   It was to be a raid that was typical of what the men had been trained for, but which they had rarely been able to conduct since arriving in the Middle East.

            On the night of 17/18 July the detachment attacked the Italian position. It proved to be highly successful, being well-planned and executed. Using the cover of darkness and a carefully laid deception plan, the commandos managed to sneak up behind the Italians position on the hills, and move thorough the forward defensive pits unchallenged. In the end they advanced to within 30 yards of the headquarters before they were challenged, and when they finally were, the force rushed the Italian defenders with sub machine guns and grenades and quickly overwhelmed them. They then withdrew from the position and returned to the garrison holding Tobruk just before the Italians could call down an artillery barrage. They suffered five casualties in the raid, one of whom later died of his wounds.

            Soon afterwards the Tobruk raid No. 8 (Guards) Commando was disbanded.  Its parent formation, Layforce, suffering from the losses suffered in the early raids and the evacuation from Crete, and stymied by lack of resources, changing strategic needs and a lack of enthusiasm for their employment by parts of the British high command, became ineffective and was itself disbanded in August. Shortly after this, upon the insistence of Sir Winston Churchill, the Middle East Commando was raised from the remnants of Layforce and some of No. 8 (Guards) Commando's personnel transferred this unit, while others, including David Stirling, Randolph Churchill, George Jellicoe and Roger Courtney went on to become part of other special forces units such as the Special Air Service, the Special Boat Section or the Long Range Desert Group.

No. 3 Commando and Wales (1 September 1941 – 23 February 1942)[29]

            Methven’s tracer card shows that he transferred to No. 3 Commando on 1 September 1941.  On 27 December 1941, the Commandos carried out a raid in Norway, on the port of Vaagso and the island of Maaloy known as Operation Archery.  However, Methven did not participate in this raid.  He was posted to the Survey Training Centre at Wynnstay Hall, Ruabon, near Wrexham, Wales on 24 November 1941.  Just why he was relieved from Commando duty and returned to survey duties at this time is not known.  This posting may have been an interim assignment and a subterfuge to prepare him for his true posting with the Special Operations Executive (SOE)[30]

London, Scotland and India (24 February 1942 – 1946)

            On 24 February 1942, presumably after a period of training, Methven was posted to the London District Transfer Camp in preparation for posting to India.  On 19 March 1942 he was in Greenock, Scotland where he embarked for India, arriving in Bombay on 22 May 1942.  Upon arrival in India he joined the 14th Battalion, 7th Rajput Regiment until his discharge from the ranks on 23 September 1942.  After his discharge he transferred to the Officer Candidate Training Unit, India from which he presumably received a commission in the Indian Army.  His tracer card is very cryptic regarding his postings during this period as he probably was working for the SOE at the time.  His time with the SOE appears to have ended in 1946, but he may not have left the Army until 1950 when his period of engagement  ended.

Figure 7.  Emblem of the S.O.E.

(Image courtesy of Wikipedia)

 

4.      MEDALS, AWARDS AND DECORATIONS

            Based on his service during World War 2 John Methven may have been awarded numerous campaign medals and perhaps some decorations as well.  Without his military service papers it is not possible to know just which medals, awards and decorations he did receive.  Further research may be done in this regard by attempting to find copies of his papers.  As mentioned in the introduction to this work the author did acquire the Haynes Medal that he was awarded while at the School of Military Engineering.   The Captain A.E. Haynes, R.E. Medal was awarded to recruits to recognize Haynes service and to commemorate his death.  Haynes was killed in action while serving with the Mashonaland Field Force in 1896.  The Haynes Medal was awarded to the Sapper in each batch of recruits in the Royal Engineers, best qualified in Field Works, after going through the recruits’ course in that subject.  Nomination for the award was made by the Officer Commanding the Royal Engineers Training Battalion at the School of Military Engineering in Chatham, Kent.  The first medals were awarded in 1902.  The medal is bronze and weighs 3 ounces.  It is 2.2 inches in diameter and has a thickness of 0.15 inch.  It is engraved on the rim in upper case letters to the recipient.

Methven’s medal is named as follows:  

1867976 SAPR J. METHVEN BEST MAN FD WORKS 126 PARTY “A” COY R.E.

 

Figure 7.  The Haynes Medal Awarded to 1867976 Sapper John Methven, R.E.
(Photograph from the author’s collection)  

5.      POST SERVICE LIFE

            No information was found regarding John Methven’s post service life except that he died in December of 1979 at the Selkirk Cottage Hospital in the Scottish Borders region.

6.       FAMILY, MARRIAGE AND PERSONAL INFORMATION[31]

Wife  

            John Methven married Helen Inglis (- 1979) – birth and marriage dates unknown.  Helen died in Selkirk Cottage Hospital on 23 June 1979.  It does not appear that John and Helen had any children.

Grand Parents  

            John Methven was the grandson of William Methven (1855-1917) and his wife Charlotte Oliver (1855-1913)..  William was born in Abernethy, Perthshire on 7 August 1855.  Charlotte Oliver was born in Newbattle, Midlothian on 25 March 1855.  William and Charlotte were married in Edinburgh on 15 October 1880.

            William died at the Royal Infirmary in Edinburgh on 17 May 1917.  Charlotte had predeceased her husband when she also died in Edinburgh on 25 August 1913.

Parents 

            John Methven’s father, John, was born in Windygates, Fife on 15 September 1882.  His mother, Janet Sime, was born in Edinburgh in 1882.  John and Janet were married in Edinburgh on 29 June 1906.  Janet died in Edinburgh in 1940 and John Methven died in Edinburgh in 1964.

Siblings

            William Sime Methven was born in Edinburgh in 1907 and died there as a 2-year old infant.

            Margaret Scott Methven was born in Edinburgh on 3 August 1908.  She married George Gibb Fairley in Edinburgh on 25 January 1936 and they had three children.  Margaret died in Edinburgh on 15 January 1967. 

            James Boswell Sime Methven (1913-1992) was born in Edinburgh on 28 June 1913.  He died on 17 March 1992.

            Oliver Methven (1920-1975) was born at Dairy and Gorgie, Midlothian on 5 January 1920.  He died at Haymarket, Midlothian on 9 November 1975. 


  ADDENDUM NO. 1

            The information contained in this addendum provides many changes to the narrative of 1867976 Lance Corporal JOHN METHVEN, Royal Engineers, which has been presented above.  These changes have come about by the acquisition of his S.O.E. Service records that were obtained from the National Archive, re:

Special Operations Executive: Personnel Files (PF Series): 1939-1946, Reference HS 9/1025/1, Subjects: Intelligence.  Re: John Methven –born 19.04.1911.

The file essentially takes up where the narrative ended; that is, from 1942 to 1946.

Figure 8.  File Cover Letter  

            This cover letter summarizes Methven’s postings from 24 June 1943 to 18 December 1945.  The original typed document did not include his name.  It appears that, for security reasons, he was assigned the number 12547 as an identifier.  His handwritten name in the center of the form was probably added by the National Archives in order to properly identify the document and file it with his other papers.  In all entries on the form he is identified as 12547 and not by name. 

            The document verifies his place of birth as Edinburgh, but it shows his date of birth as 19 April 1911 and not 1910 as previously thought.  The document was prepared while he was as an officer in the Indian Army serving with the Rajput Regiment.

            Most of the entries are self-explanatory, although some of the abbreviations have not been found in any list of military abbreviations during the World War 2 period.  On 24 June 1943 he was in the Primary Training Corps (P.T.C.), Indian Army as was being considered for employment in the S.O.E.  From 30 June 1943 he was employed in the Marine Section in India until 1 July 1943 when it appears that his duties changed (the symbol B/B729 was allotted?).  On 30 March 1944 he arrived in the U.K. from New Delhi and then on 18 September 1944 he proceeded to Australia.  An entry on the form dated 21 November 1944 indicates that he had been posted to Force 136 with effect from (w.e.f.) 10 April 1944.

            Force 136 was a far eastern branch of the British World War II intelligence organisation, the Special Operations Executive (S.O.E.). Originally set up in 1941 as the India Mission with the cover name of GSI(k), it absorbed what was left of S.O.E.'s Oriental Mission in April 1942. The man in overall charge for the duration of its existence was Colin Mackenzie.
            The organisation was established to encourage and supply indigenous resistance movements in enemy-occupied territory, and occasionally mount clandestine sabotage operations. Force 136 operated in the regions of the South-East Asian Theatre of World War II which were occupied by Japan from 1941 to 1945: Burma, Malaya, China, Sumatra, Siam, and French Indochina (FIC).

            Although the top command of Force 136 were British officers and civilians, most of those it trained and employed as agents were indigenous to the regions in which they operated. Burmese, Indians and Chinese were trained as agents for missions in Burma, for example. British and other European officers (Lieutenant Methven, for example) and NCOs went behind the lines to train resistance movements. Former colonial officials and men who had worked in these countries for various companies knew the local languages, the peoples and the land and so became invaluable to S.O.E. Most famous amongst these officers are Freddie Spencer Chapman in Malaya and Hugh Seagrim in Burma. 

            The last entry on this form made on 18 December 1945 shows that Methven was transferred to other units within the S.O.E.; that is, M.E.80 to M.E.100 and B/B(I) to B/B(A) Sections with effect from 26 October 1945.  Just what these sections were have not been uncovered by the author.  Much can be learned regarding the organization of the S.O.E. by referring to the following web site:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Operations_Executive#Subsidiary_branches

            The next document in Methven’s S.O.E. file is his S.O.E. RECORD OF SERVICE.  The entries on the form in script were presumably made by Methven.

Section I.- PERSONAL PARTICULARS

FULL NAME

JOHN METHVEN.

PERMANENT ADDRESS AND TELEPHONE NUMBER

 

10. Springwell Place Edinburgh

DATE AND PLACE OF BIRTH

19.4.11. Edinburgh

NATIONALITY:

(a)   At birth

(b)   Present

 

 

Scottish
  

EDUCATION:

(a)   Schools

(b)   Universities

Subjects read

Degrees taken

 

Tynecastle High Grade School Edinburgh

RELIGIOUS DENOMINATION

Presbyterian

MARRIED OR SINGLE

M.

PARTICULARS OF WIFE OR HUSBAND:

(a)   Maiden name of wife or full name of husband

 

(b)   Present nationality

(c)    Nationality at birth

(d)   Date and place of birth

(e)    Present address

 

 

 

Helene Madelaine Skinner

British

British

Parish 9/7/20.

On Service

PARTICULARS OF CHILDREN:

Names and dates of birth

 

/

PARTICULARS OF PARENTS:

(a)   Father (i) Name

(ii) Dated and place of birth

(iii) Nationality at birth and

       present nationality

(b)   Mother (i) Maiden name

  (ii) Date and place of birth

 (iii) Nationality at birth and

        present nationality

 

JOHN METHVEN

9.9.82. Fifeshire

Scottish

 

JANET SIME.

9.5.84 Edinburgh

 

Scottish

NEXT OF KIN (other than wife or husband):

 

Name, address and relationship

Father

John Methven. 10 Springwell Place
Edinburgh

BANKERS OR AGENTS:

(a) Home

(b) Abroad


National Bank of Scotland. Princes St. Edinburgh

Commonwealth Bank of Australia, Freemantle

 

Section II.- QUALIFICATIONS

CIVILIAN OCCUPATION

By Whom employed, nature of employment and date in each case

 

 

1/2500 Draughtsman (Ordnance Survey)

1.11.26 – 30.4.29.

PROFESSIONAL, TECHNICAL OR OTHER QUALIFICATIONS

 

1/2500 Reviser

Slight knowledge of Topo Surveying

                      Trig Surveying      

LANGUAGE QUALIFICATIONS

Degree of proficiency to be indicated, i.e. bi-lingual, fluent, working knowledge

 

Language

Speak

Read

Write

Urdu

-          Working knowledge -

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

KNOWLEDGE OF FOREIGN COUNTRIES

 

Country

Length of Visit

Purpose of Visit

India

2 years

Military Duty

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SPECIAL KNOWLEDGE AND EXPERIENCE

 

 

SPORTING ACHIEVEMENTS, e.g. Riding, Sailing, Shooting, Flying, Games, Boxing, Diving, Mountaineering, etc., and degree of proficiency

 

Golf, Football, Hill Climbing, Swimming - average

HOBBIES AND OTHER INTERESTS

 

 

 

Section III.- MILITARY HISTORY

PERSONAL NUMBER

 

REGIMENT OR CORPS

VIIth RAJPUTS

NATURE AND DATE OF COMMISSION

 

Emergency War  20.9.42.

HONOURS, REWARDS

(including Mentions in Despatches)

 

 

MEDICAL CATEGORY AND HISTORY

Category:- A.1.

MILITARY COURSES OF INSTRUCTION

 

School

Date

Type of Course and Result

Aldershot P.T.

1937

Long course Q.1.

Tregantle

1939

Gas  Q.1

Loch Ailort

1940

Special Service Q.1.

Rawalpindi

1942

Unarmed combat Q.1.

Poona

1942

Tactics  Q.1.

RECORD OF PROMOTION

Rank

Date

Authority

Lcpl

1937

Pt II Orders

Cpl

1939

Survey Battn R.E.

Sgt

1940

 

Cadet

1942

 

Lieut

20.9.42.

 

DETAILS OF MILITARY SERVICE

Joined Corps of Royal Engineers 1.5.29.

Recruits course at Chatham till 1.6.30.

Joined Survey Battn R.E. 1.6.30 and was engaged on Survey work of different kinds in U.K. till mobilization in Sept. 1939. Served as P.T. and drill instructor till June 1940 and joined No. 3 Commando till November 1941. Was engaged in Lofoten Raid Norway March 1941. Served in India from May 1942 being commissioned at Dehra Dun Academy. Served on the N.W. Frontier Sept 1942 – May 1943.

 

Section III.- ACCOUNT OF SERVICE WITH S.O.E.

SPECIAL REMARKS

Joined 1.6.43.  Served with 85 Company

Mora (Bombay)

 

S.O.E. COURSES OF INSTRUCTION

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Australia

Australia

School

Date

Type of Course and Result

Poona

June 1943

Small arms & Demolitions

Calcutta

Aug-Sept 1943

Elementary Navigation

Bombay

Feb 1944

Short Oerlikon course(1)

Loch Striven

May 1944

M.F.U.(2) (uncompleted)

H.M.S. James Cook(3).

July 1944

Pilotage

H.M.S. Cookham(3)

August 1944

Naval Signalling, Short Course

C.B.C. Garden Island

Nov-Dec 1944

S.B(4) (uncompleted)

F.C.S.(5)

Apr-May 1945

Basic Course

 

NOTES:

1.      An Oerlikon is a short 20mm cannon.

2.      M.F.U.  Mobile Flotation Unit.

3.      No information could be found for either of these two ship.

4.      S.B.  Stretcher Bearer?  This is the only meaning of the abbreviation S.B. that could be found in U.K. military abbreviations, but it seem unlikely that he was being trained by the S.O.E. to be a Stretcher Bearer.

5.      Fire Command South?

 

CHRONOLOGICAL RECORD OF SERVICE WITH S.O.E.:-

Date

Section

Postings, Transfers, Promotion, Appointments, Nature of Duties, Casualties, etc.(1)

1.6.43

85 Company

Training Pathans in assault landings.

1.8.43

Naval

To learn naval work in small craft.

Oct 43-

Feb 44

  

Acting First Officer in native shore Malabar Coast.

17.3.44

  

Posted to Britain on naval courses.

18.9.44

  

Proceeded to Australia.

22.10.44

  

Posted to C.B.C. Garden Island (Australia)(2)

26.10.44

B/B(A)

From ME 80 as Gns. Officer to be Br. Fd. Staff within M.E.100.

7.1.45

 

Posted to F.E.S. as Folboat Instructor.(3)

17.12.45

 

Released in Australia

 

 

? (Service in Borneo)(4)

 

NOTE: 

1.      The handwritten entries in Methven’s script are difficult to read in some places.  Some errors may have been made by the author in deciphering his writing.

2.      The meaning of the abbreviation C.B.C. could not be determined.

3.      The “Folboat” referred to probably refers to folding kayaks sometimes used by Special Forces units.  The meaning of the abbreviation F.E.S. could not be determined.

4.      This entry about “Service in Borneo” is not understood.

             Methen's  documents indicates that he left the Army in January of 1946 as a Lieutenant in the 7th Rajput Regiment, Indian Army and that his demobilization took place in Western Australia. 

            The S.O.E. documents add much to Methven’s story and fill in many of the blanks in his service that exist in the original narrative.  The documents provide more information regarding his posting and commissioning in the Indian Army, information that was not included on his tracer cards.  They also provide more definitive data regarding his service in the 7th Rajputs and what he was doing between 1942 and 1946.  These documents do, however, add some confusion to his story as well.  The biggest controversy introduced by the S.O.E. papers is where Methven claims to have been engaged in the Lofoten Raid in Norway in March 1941.  The Lofoten Raid was codenamed Operation Claymore.  The Lofoten Islands were an important centre for the production of fish oil and glycerine, used in the German war economy. The landings were carried out on 4 March 1941, by the men of No. 3 Commando, No. 4 Commando, a Royal Engineers section (in which Methven must have served) and 52 men from the Norwegian Independent Company 1. Supported by the 6th Destroyer Flotilla and two troop transports of the Royal Navy, the force made an unopposed landing and generally continued to meet no opposition. The original plan was to avoid contact with German forces and inflict the maximum of damage to German-controlled industry. They achieved their objective of destroying fish oil factories and some 3,600 t (3,500 long tons) of oil and glycerine. The British experienced only one accident; an officer injuring himself with his own revolver and returned with some 228 German prisoners, 314 loyal Norwegian volunteers and a number of Quisling regime collaborators.

            Through naval gunfire and demolition parties, 18,000 tons of shipping were sunk. Perhaps the most significant outcome of the raid was the capture of a set of rotor wheels for an Enigma machine and its code books from the German armed trawler Krebs. German naval codes could be read at Bletchley Park, providing the intelligence needed to allow Allied convoys to avoid U-boat concentrations. In the aftermath, the evaluation of the operation differed, with the British, especially Winston Churchill and the Special Operations Executive, deeming it a success. In the eyes of the British the main value of such actions was to tie up large German forces on occupation duties in Norway.

            What is confusing about Methven’s participation in the Lofoten Raid is that his Royal Engineers Tracer Card does not put him in No. 3 Commando until 1 September 1941, some six months after the raid.  The tracer cards indicate that he was is No. 8 Commando at that time.  Of course the cards could be wrong or Methven might have been “on loan” to No. 3 Commando when the raid took place.  This is probably the most significant conflict between his R.E. records and his S.O.E. regards, but the author is happy to consider that Methven did take part in the raid.

            In addition to the details above regarding his posting to the S.O.E., Methven’s documents provide many additional bits of data regarding his life and military career that are not fully covered in the main narrative of this report.

SECTION I. – PERSONAL PARTICULARS

a)      Methven’s parents dates and place of birth and where he lived as a child.  The building at 10 Springwell Place in Edinburgh is a multi-story building that obviously was (and still is) the home of a number of families.

b)      Methven was educated at Tynecastle High School, a school was opened in 1912 and located at 15 McLeod Street in Edinburgh during the time that he attended school.

Figure 9.  Tynecastle High School, Edinburgh.
(Photograph courtesy of the Edinburgh News)  

c)      John Methven’s wife was Helene Madelaine Skinner, a British subject born in France on 9 July 1920.  This name is different than the name shown in Section 6 of the narrative; that is, Helen Inglis.  The name Helen Inglis was found in the family trees posted on Ancestry.com and unless Methven was married twice, the name Helen Inglis may be an error.  There is a confusing entry in the section dealing with the PARTICULARS OF WIFE on his form.  Where the present address of his wife is asked for, Methven entered “On Service.”  This could mean that his wife was serving in one of the branches of the armed forces or Methven could have made an error thinking that the question was asking for his present address.

d)     Methven’s religion is shown as Presbyterian on the form.

SECTION II. – QUALIFICATIONS

            This section of Methven’s S.O.E. forms provides information about his surveying qualifications, his foreign language qualifications, time spent in India and his sporting achievements.  None of this information was available to the author when the original narrative was written.

SECTION III. – MILITARY HISTORY

            The information contained in this section is very useful in filling in the gaps of the narrative.  It contains information that would be found in his service papers if they were obtained from the Army Personnel Centre in Glasgow.  The dates provided for his military courses and promotions only provide the years and note the specific dates, although his date of commissioning in the Indian Army is given definitively as 20 September 1942.  The DETAILS OF MILITARY SERVICE provided by Methven are excellent, giving a concise summary of his service.

SECTION IV. – ACCOUNT OF SERVICE WITH THE S.O.E.

            Again, this section provides more complete information regarding John Methven’s military service, although some of the entries on the form are difficult to understand because of the abbreviations used.  According to Methven, he joined the S.O.E. on 1 June 1943 while serving with the 85th Company in Bombay.  He had been commissioned in the Indian Army for the Dehra Dun Academy and was posted to the 7th Rajput Regiment.  He then served on the North West Frontier of India from September 1942 to May 1943 while with the 7th Rajputs.  The significance of the “85th Company” is not understood by the author. 

            During World War 2 the 7th Rajput Regiment had five battalions and a training battalion.  Methven does not indicate in which battalion he served and no information has been uncovered to show that any battalion ever served on the North West Frontier in 1942 or 1943.

EPILOGUE

            John Methven’s S.O.E. papers added a lot to his story and were useful in correcting a number of errors made in the original narrative.  It is hoped that someday his full service papers can be retrieved that a more complete and accurate story can be told. 


REFERENCES (for 69348 Sapper John Methven)

Book  

History of the Corps of Royal Engineers, Volume V.  The Institution of Royal Engineers, Chatham, Kent, 1952, pp. 231-232.

 Family Trees  

 John Methven (moragelsa66)

https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/5277865/person/-1132486504/facts  

Internet Web Sites  

Commonwealth War Graves Commission.

http://www.cwgc.org  

Military Documents  

  1. Great War Medal Index Card.
  2. Royal Engineers Medal Roll, 1914-15 Star.
  3. Royal Engineers Medal Roll, British War Medal and Victory Medal.
  4. War Diary, 138th Army Troops Company, August 1915 to November 1919.

Periodicals  

The Royal Engineers Journal.  The Institution of Royal Engineers, Chatham, Kent, 1925-1932.  


REFERENCES (for 1867976 Lance Corporal John Methven)  

Internet Web Sites  

  1. John Methven Family Tree (silverknowles): Son, John Methven (1910-1979)

https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/13545677/person/-49417477/facts  

  1. John Methven Family Tree (silverknowles): Father, John Methven (1882-1965)

https://www.ancestry.com/family-tree/person/tree/13545677/person/-49417476/facts  

  1. Wikipedia: No. 3 Commando.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No._3_Commando

  1. Wikipedia: No. 8 Commando.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No._8_(Guards)_Commando

 

5.      Earl and Dickies
.

https://www.facebook.com/984271655005243/posts/the-special-operations-executive-soe-was-a-british-world-war-ii-organisation-it-/2051509598281438/  

Military Documents  

Royal Engineers Tracer Cards  

National Archives  

Special Operations Executive: Personnel Files (PF Series): 1939-1946, Reference HS 9/1025/1, Subjects: Intelligence.  Re: John Methven –born 19.04.1911.  

Periodicals  

The Sapper, July 1934, p. 338.


ENDNOTES:

[1] History of the Corps of Royal Engineers, Volume V.

[2] War diary.

[3] Major John Palgrave Heathcote Ouchterlony (1884-1917) was the son of Lt.-Col. Thomas Heathcote Ouchterlony and Mary Ann Wilmot.

                Dec. 1901:            From the RMA Woolwich he passed into the Royal Engineers.

                26 Sep 1908:         Married Constance Kathleen Gaisford Spackman in St Mary's R.C. Church, Cadogan Street, Chelsea, London.

                Jan 1910:              Specially employed as Head of the Roads Department in the Ashanti area , West Africa

                Dec 1912:             Promoted Captain

                Aug 1915:             Proceeded to France

                Dec 1916:             Promoted Major

                Jun 7th 1917:       Killed in action and originally buried near Fosse Wood , Zillebeke

[4] War diary.

[5] Methven’s first name and his date of deployment to France are clearly shown on his Medal Index Card.

[6] History of the Corps of Royal Engineers, Volume V.

[7] Battle Honours of the Royal Engineers and the company war diary.

[8] Powell, aged 37, was the husband of Emily Powell, of 13, Hermitage St., Paddington Green, London.

[9] Devine, aged 24, was the son of Philip and Agnes Devine, of  Scotstoun, Renfrewshire.

[10] Goodhead, from Burton-on-Trent, Staffordshire.

[11] Smith, aged 43, son of John Preston Smith and Sally Smith, of Hadlow Down, Uckfield, Sussex; husband of Mrs. E. Smith, of The Porch, New Road, Buxted, Sussex.

[12] Baker, husband of E. B. Simpson (formerly Baker), of 10, Waldeck Rd., Strand-on-the-Green, Chiswick, London.

[13] Smith, aged 30, son of C. W. and Jane Smith, of Suite 6, Post Office Chambers, Fort William, Ontario. Native of Suffolk, England.

[14] Whittet, aged 26, son of Peter and Bessie Jane Whittet, of 110, Market St., St. Andrews.  His given name may have been Joseph.

[15] Chad, aged 40, Son of John and Frances Chad, of 30, Exeter St., Marylebone, London; husband of Johanna Chad, of 11, Church Place, Paddington Green, London.

[16] Colley, aged 38, Son of Benjamin Colley, of Church Stretton, Salop; husband of Ethel Colley, of 3, New St., Bishop's Castle, Salop.

[17] Medal Index Card.

[18] Royal Engineer Medal rolls.

[19] John Methven family tree.

[20] Royal Engineers Tracer Card.

[21] Later Colonel, OBE. Deceased, 9 November 1987.

[22] Later Lieutenant General, KBE, GC, CB.  Deceased, 7 January 1993.

[23] Royal Engineers Tracer Card.

[24] Later Major General, CB, DSO, MC. Deceased, 4 August 1962.

[25] Later Colonel.  Deceased, 15 December 1983.

[26] Wikipedia: No. 8 Commando.

[27] Layforce was an ad hoc military formation of the British Army consisting of a number of commando units during the Second World War. Formed in February 1941 under the command of Colonel Robert Laycock, after whom the force was named, it consisted of approximately 2,000 men and served in the Middle Eastern theatre of operations.

[28] Later Major General, KCMG, CB, DSO, KStJ.  Deceased, 10 March 1968.

[29] Wikipedia: No. 3 Commando.

[30] See The National Archives reference HS 9/1025/1.

[31] Various family trees on Ancestry.com.